To make the most of your content, you need to make sure you're integrating correctly with social media, using the most effective tools at your disposal, and most importantly, continuing to pay attention to it long after you launch it. In today's Whiteboard Friday, Ben Lloyd and Brian Rauschenbach tell you about the various tools and tactics that can maximize the reach of your hard work.
For reference, here's a still of this week's whiteboard!
Helpful links mentioned this week
Peter Bray's Twitter Tweet-Life Study
Video transcription
Ben: Hey Mozzers. My name is Ben Lloyd. I'm a principal at Add3, which is a search marketing agency with offices in Seattle and Portland.
Brian: And I'm Brian Rauschenbach, President of Add3, and I work day-to-day directly with Ben on both paid and organic channels. What we're hoping to achieve with our session today is to help you basically take the content that you've invested time and money into to help you amplify it and make some more noise with it. What we want to do is basically revisit some of the fundamentals and the foundation of what we're probably all doing today and how we can make that a little better. So let's get right into it.
The usual
Ben: Sure. So here's kind of a typical scenario that I see when people are spending time building and launching content, is they kind of go through the same process all of the time. They'll launch it. Great. Post is done. Ideally, they've done their content strategy, and they know who they're talking to. They've optimized the post, done a little bit of SEO, got an original image in there or two or three or whatever. They'll put it up. They'll promote it, which typically means, "Hey guys, a new post is up." Hopefully, they are even doing this. The corporate account will tweet it, and then you'll ask team or whoever at the company to tweet it, like it on the Facebook, and whatever else, and then kind of nothing.
People sort of hope, well, maybe it will gain a life of its own. They'll pray about it. I don't know. Most likely they just tend to forget about it and move on to the next thing.
The results always kind of work like this. You see the life of a post kind of goes, "Hey, it's up. It's live." We do a little bit of a social bump to it, and this number could be anywhere from 50 to 5,000 or whatever. But you get some visits for it, and then the tweets and whatever else die off. It kind of just dies down, and that's really all you get out of it. So it will sort of peter out. If you do a good job with organic and some on-site optimization, maybe you'll do okay, and then this little smiley face Rand [pointing to the whiteboard] doesn't really smile. He just doesn't really think it's that great.
Brian: Yeah. We're putting all of this time into this content, and the life cycle feels like it's just not . . . the reward for it, it doesn't real. I think that that's probably the biggest challenge now in getting people to really grasp content and why we should be developing great content is you put all of this time into it, you get these results back, and this is our cycle that we're in right now.
Ben: It bums you out. Right?
Brian: Yeah.
Social life of content
Ben: When you think about it, if this is all of the promotion that you're doing for your content, and you see study after study talk about the life cycle or the average life span or the shelf life of a tweet or a social post, there's a Bitly study recently that said the average shelf life of a link in three hours. Peter, here at Moz Followerwonk, he has his own, about just Twitter alone. Basically, 18 minutes is all you get out of that thing, and then you get the bulk of your results out of it.
So from a social standpoint, when you really start to think about it, if that's all you do to promote your piece of content, this is really all that you can expect out of it, that short-term visibility. Then, again, maybe you do okay with organic or whatever, but that's all you get.
Brian: Yeah. So if we're getting back to basics, we're doing all of this today it feels like, right, and we feel good. But what are some things that you've sort of seen in audit phases, when you're looking at other people's social?
Ben: Well, these results are kind of depressing, right?
Brian: Yeah.
Ben: It doesn't impress anybody at the company when you're like, "Hey, we got a couple of hundred visits, and that was about it." That mileage varies depending on your following.
So there are a couple of areas that I would really like to look at that are super obvious from a blocking and tackling, real basic standpoint. Then we'll get into some other stuff.
Social integration
But the very first thing that I like to get into, when I look at sites and content and their social strategy, I don't even go to their social account. I don't even look at what they've been doing. I just go to their page where they're trying to share stuff. (A) Do they have buttons at all for sharing, and (B) what happens when you click on them?
So this is one area that I think is overlooked a lot, because when people at the company or whatever, the social guy goes to share content, he uses Hootsuite or something like that, or she, and they'll post it using that tool and they never actually interact with the buttons. But your visitor doesn't do it that way. So one thing that happens is if you aren't tightened up there, you'll click that "tweet this" button, and you'll see some things like...
Brian: Random image.
Ben: Yeah, or like if they haven't done title tags, God forbid, it's just some generic title tag. In Facebook, maybe it's a random image from the page. The description isn't good, that kind of thing.
Brian: Or it's just pulling in something generic.
Ben: Yeah, absolutely.
Brian: Which is why sort of the Open Graph thing is so big for us to be investing time in developing what the description is, making sure your images are friendly with the content you're pushing out.
Ben: Precisely. Yeah. So when you do your Open Graph tags, make sure that description is tight. Make sure you're pulling in a featured image, etc. Sometimes you have to get a dev involved, because you're just taking what the plug-in gives you, depending on your site. But just take a look at what's happening there when you do that.
Then the other thing that I think that fits in with this button idea and Open graph is just aligning your sharing to your audience. I think a lot of people...
Brian: We're all guilty of this, right? We put up everything.
Ben: Absolutely. You go to a site and like, "Man, I can't choose between which buttons to share." I don't want people to not share something on -- I don't even know -- some random social network. But if you've done the work that you should be doing with your content strategy, you should know who you're trying to reach, who your personas are, who is this person you want to have reading your content, and what action do you want them to take.
Brian: So this would be business content, maybe marketing-related?
Ben: So business, B2B, etc. This guy, with his little tie, he'd be somebody you'd want to see more on sharing your content on LinkedIn or Twitter. Since we're in search and marketing or whatever, Google+ we like to see. But in a different context, maybe targeting female shoppers, you don't really care about LinkedIn. So why do you have that button on the page? So Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook, those are the places maybe that audience lives at a little bit more. So know who you are trying to reach and align that sharing to that audience.
Brian: Yeah, I like it. Then if we get into some sort of deeper, social promotional pieces here, or with Twitter cards, yeah.
Ben: Yeah, let's jump in on Twitter cards real quick. But it totally aligns with this better social promotion. Twitter cards are like really easy to implement, and it's been around for a while. I don't really think a lot of people do it, except marketing guys.
Brian: Well, we all ignored it for a while, right?
Ben: Yeah, everybody ignored it.
Brian: But this is a great tool, because it feels like if you get in, even though now is not early, but if you're adopting it now, the results that we're seeing from our Twitter cards and our posts, this is sort of a screenshot of what we pulled out of our analytics, and what we've been seeing is that we're using a summary card for most of our blog posts, and we're getting 2.5X, may 3X in retweets just because we have the Twitter card enabled. Like Ben was saying, it's pretty easy to implement. It feels like it's just like setting up a Webmaster Tools account and doing some meta tag authentication and almost the same type of work you'd be doing with your OG tags.
Ben: Pretty much. The process is spelled out here, dev.twitter.com/cards. It's really straightforward, a little bit of tag implementation, verification. It's kind of like doing structured markup a little bit, but then you have to get it approved. But I've done a couple of them lately, and it comes back almost instantaneously now.
Better social promotion
Brian: That's great. Yeah, jumping into some other social promotional things, I think Rand had a Whiteboard Friday session recently where he was talking about frequency and timing, and I think this is a piece that we're all sort of guilty of, right? We put the blog post up, and like you said, we're on to the next one. What's some good advice you have on revisiting and doing this piece here?
Ben: Yeah. When you kind of consider the cycle here and the way that these normally go, and again you really take a step back and you're like, "Three hours?" Are you really going to reach the people you're trying to reach? Are they on Twitter for that three hours? Is that even something that they're interested in at that point in time, etc.? So I this frequency and timing is a big deal, and there are obviously tools like Followerwonk, that is in the Moz toolset, that you can analyze your own followers, see when they're online, or when they're on Twitter and that kind of thing. But you can kind of do the same thing with Facebook and some of the other channels.
A lot of people put it up once and that's it. One and done is not the way to do this. I'm not suggesting that you go and hammer away all day for 24 hours on a specific post. But if you're a little bit judicious about it and you think about how to space that out, and is this post still relevant next week and next month, and two months from now, then why do you stop promoting it after that first day or week?
Brian: Yeah. Another thing I think we're all guilty of is we basically pulled the post back up out of our inbox and repost it, just how it was the original time, and this is an area I think that not a lot of people are taking full advantage of, is basically testing your messaging. You have a couple of examples here that you can walk through.
Ben: Absolutely. So a couple of ways to kind of vary, and I actually struggle with this a lot, because we worked so hard on the title tag, I just want to use that as the tweet or the post or whatever. That always happens. So your title always gets out there as kind of a tweet behind that post. But some other things you should try pulling a quote out of your content, using some sort of key takeaway that's in there. Maybe it's a bullet that's already in there or a headline or something. But using those takeaways, maybe including a stat, which I guess is technically a takeaway, or adding some commentary. So for example, your post might be how to do X in three steps. But then your commentary, like Miles on our team, he always does this like, "Revolutionize the way you do X. Here's three steps how," or whatever. Like he'll kind of retweet stuff, and sometimes those tend to work a lot better than your static title. So I'd say trying those out and seeing what works.
Brian: Yeah, and then you could take sort of the results that you're getting from that message testing and apply it to the next post.
Ben: Exactly. I think the last there here, and this is simple stuff, real basic, but at least in an agency setting, the pace is constant, and you don't always have time for thinking about it, but my friend, Sarah, likes to say, "Don't cross the streams," when it comes to her social channels, from "Ghostbusters" there. But when you put something on Twitter, and you've got this great tool that like I can also post the exact same thing to Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn, or whatever at the same time, don't just copy/paste, because it doesn't translate.
Brian: It doesn't translate.
Ben: So you should have @ symbols and hashtags in Twitter. But on LinkedIn, you don't want to do that kind of thing. Really optimizing for the channel, it's kind of like a key takeaway there.
Paid social amplification
Brian: Yeah, cool. So sort of jumping into the other piece, which is basically pay to play, we're testing in there, and we're getting great results from it. We've been talking to a lot of other peers, and everyone seems to be dipping their toes in here. But it feels like this is the area where we can really do the amplification piece with our content. I think some of the stuff that we've been looking at recently and I think in Facebook ads, you see that boost button underneath your post, and it's so tempting to just say boost my post. It just basically pushes it out to all of your friends, and it's almost the same bad effect I think when I put like a post on Facebook. It's like my family and my friends that aren't in the industry, and they're like, "Yeah, I'll support Brian. Let me give him a like too."
But that's not who I was trying to reach with this post. So spend some time in Facebook ads and define that segment of the person that you're trying to go after. It's really easy in there, and once you build those segments, you can reuse them for a future post.
Promote a tweet. We're doing a lot of good stuff here, and that I think to your frequency and timing thing, it's where you can really go after the person that you want to see that post that you've spent all of this time and resources into. So you could just use their handles and target them directly or also just target by topic and category.
The StumbleUpon has been a really interesting test. It's paid discovery, and so it's really sort of top of funnel stuff. We see a lot of interaction in there, especially if the content that you've produced matches up with the topic or the categories that they have.
Ben: Yeah, one of the categories that they have available. Absolutely.
Brian: Then Outbrain, if you want to go down, I call this shock content -- the 13 best cities for hippies to live in, which is actually a real article somewhere that I came across. But this is a content that lives on CNET on the bottom of the page. It's like more from the Web, and it's just another area where you could probably earn some links and also social shares.
Ben: Sure. I think the big thing here is, being an SEO guy and being that this is Moz and that's this community that we're in, to me, again, I think you've stated it already, but like to spend time and energy in developing your content and then to not sort of just give it that kick that it needs to kind of get it kind of spinning, Moz spends a lot of great time and energy on giving you great tips about how to participate with the community and your kind of like organic outreach that you can do behind content. But a lot of people are really just trying to get up and get going, generate that visibility for their content. I really think it's worthwhile to consider paid social amplification.
I really don't consider this the new "link building." But I think if you do a lot of these things and you get your content out in front of the right people, and you spend some money putting it in front of the right eyeballs, good things happen with your organic if you've spent time and energy on creating good content.
Brian: Yeah. It's also really important that we've been sort of advocates for content for it feels like the last 2.5 years, and it feels like a lot of our clients are embracing it and their management is embracing it. It's like we don't want this to happen. It's like we finally got everyone onboard to say, "Yeah, let's build content, great content, and push this out there." If this is what the results that we're reporting back to our clients and their bosses . . .
Ben: Nobody's going to be excited about it.
Brian: . . . no one is going to keep on investing in it. So I think that if we're having a full team of copywriters and marketers behind this, and we're pushing this content out, we should also budget for pay channels as well.
Ben: Sure. So I think that's really pretty much it. So thanks for having us.
Brian: Yeah, thanks for having us. We'll be around watching the comments and for any questions that we might be able to answer. So thanks Mozzers.
Nice #wbf guys. Good stuff on buttons...frustrating to see the wrong sharing buttons on blog posts. Your 'better social promotion' tips play well with the excellent tips in this post (not a fan of KM or NP but this post is legit): https://blog.kissmetrics.com/double-your-social-med...
That post is a solid bookmark and when combined with your tips here should yield real results.
Josh - I know that post well and it's entirely probable that it informed our content. :) I really like the chart he has on that post that shows the social posting timeline by channel. I am pretty sure Rand used it in a WBF recently as well.
Hey Guys Congratulations you have done a great job :) I would like to say that I enjoyed the video and thanks for sharing with us this useful information :)
See the previous lessons it's helpful to :)
Nicely presented and compiled guys, thanks for sharing.
I feel better informed on how best to handle the Blog -> World transition on the back of this info, will definitely look to get our Twitter cards in order and take note of the '18 minute' rule!
Paid is indeed the way forward, but it has to be a decent piece of content to begin with if it's to avoid paling into sheer insignificance by the time the proverbial ink is dry on it.
Nice summary, thanks. I will be implementing Twitter cards asap.
Since social networks act like news feeds, I think it's a little spammy to keep posting old content. Perhaps its more useful to widen your sharing to external blogs and forums, using your content as a form of citation (assuming it's actually useful).
Internal linking is also key when it comes to getting readers to stay on the site and discover old content.
Agreed, as far as re-posting content on social networks. If I see the same thing more than twice from you, you are instantly un-followed!
Great jobs guy! I really liked how much you emphasized the social integration with your content and trying to better optimize your social shares for each channel (realize how g+, facebook, twitter & linkedin are different from each other).
Been doing a lot of this. I will have to try the twitter cards. Thanks for the advice. What are your thoughts on using PPC to get your content in front of people? I have been doing this for content and it gets good traction.
We tested Outbrain for a bit to put some paid content promotion, but what we found was that while did drive significant traffic, most of the traffic bounced. As we all know, an increase in bounce rate can really hinder SEO efforts, so we ultimately moved away from the model. With the right type of content, however, I could see the paid model working really well.
Jake - We have been testing the content distribution sites like Outbrain for content that you see on the footers of CNN articles but like Chase said bounce rates are high but if you can get the content shared from that type of channel then it might be worth it to you.
We have also looked at Zemanta and Taboola as other paid content amplification channels outside of the social networks. Taboola has a $2k per month minimum and you get up to 2 sites per account with a dedicated account manager. Let us know if anyone has used them as we would love some feedback.
We have used Taboola quite a bit over the last 6 months. We find that the publisher network is significantly larger, the costs are lower (we typically get it down to a $0.10 CPC or lower) and the algorithm for content distribution seems to be more even. With Outbrain we see 2-3 pieces out of 20 eventually dominate 99% of impressions within 3 weeks as the algorithm declares them to be best performers, Taboola rotates content much more evenly.
We do tend to see a significantly high bounce rate on Taboola as well.
I have implemented Twitter LGC & Website cards and found them working. These card are better in TOFU approach and also a good way for getting a whole list of e mails for any marketing campaign. In case of Facebook & other platforms, timing is the key for sure. Prior page insight analysis is very important when it comes to Facebook. For Twitter, a lot of platforms such ad TweetDeck & Follower-wonk would help in figuring the insight and creating a strategy. In this context the schedule from Kissmetrics is something that I always follow. Anyway, Great post guys.
"Don't cross the streams." Love it!
I've seen the 18 minutes for Twitter here on Moz and have used it often. Why do you suppose the number is drastically different for Twitter on Bitly's Study (2.8 Hours)? Is it the nature of each of Bitly's tweets has a link where Peter Bray's study does not?
Edit: It seems Bitly used 1,000 popular bitly links. Probably a massive determining factor.
I've tried looking into the half-life of social media posts for a while and this discrepancy is fascinating (not to mention large).
Looks like it's time to push Peter to dig a little more into it as he suggested we do.
We work w/ a brand that puts up a recipe of the month and the most long-term social traffic we see them getting is from Pinterest--even a post over a year old sends hundreds of referral visits a month.
I wish I could say we were directly responsible for that amplification but it's been completely serendipitous.
Regardless, it would be interesting to see what that looks like more broadly across various verticals.
Joseph -
totally fascinating discrepancy. I tend to just focus on the directional nature of these studies (or any other) rather than the hard numbers. When you boil it all down the real story is that the shelf-life is short. It's like when you see those CTR studies and one says the CTR for organic ranking #1 is 30-something% and another says 18% or something. At the end of the day - #1 gets more than #10. :)
Thanks @Ben Lloyd and @Brian Rauschenbach...It really explored my knowledge...It gave me more confident to write more content and just explore it by using social tools...:)
Thanks Ben and Brian, a timely share after Panda 4.0 where content and social are the hot topic for us Digital marketers.
a great piece on the paid amplification and twitter cards
Great conversation Ben & Brian.... Thanks for content amplifying advice in social point of view.
I really liked this post.
My conclusion on your article.. I have covered main points
It will be useful for my next content marketing campaign...
Stop it, your giving us all the answers! Great post
Aw, thanks for the mention in the video, Ben! I am indeed a firm believer in providing unique commentary to incentivize click-through. Although it’s not the be-all-end-all, it’s important to use every weapon in your arsenal to attract searchers to your listing instead of others.
P.S. Great WBF! I think this video highlights some big social opportunities that most companies miss out on.
Make sure sharing on mobile is easy as well. I remember the days on Search Engine Land when it was nearly impossible to share from a mobile device on their site... they have since tightened it up to be very user friendly.
Great video, especially on the buttons. I'm shocked how little those buttons seem to be tested on blogs and newspaper sites. One small note, when I do retweet something from a site with multiple authors, I spend about 10 secs looking up the writer's Twitter name and add that in the tweet. He or she deserves credit for the hard work!
OG Tags and specially Twitter Cards are a lot like homework used to be back in the days: You know you should do it but you always procrastinate it.
I have seen some very well optimized websites, and from my experience the ones that successfully combine (all other factors being equal) OG Tagas, Twitter Cards and some sort of microdata formatting, always rank better.
Thanks guys!
Content + SEO + Social Media = Win
Content + SEO + Poor Social Media = Good luck!
This should be pretty basic but as you said it's more likely to see people failing at it. Everyone sooner or later started to invest into content but most of them end up wasting money to produce content that none will ever read. Best thing is to prove with that after months of content by it self the ROI is still 0.
This happens because some companies still treat channels separately and don't go for an organic investment. Especially when engagement signals from both on-site and off-site point of view are getting more important, there is no way you can win with only the Organic search channel leading the game.
Content + SEO + Poor Social Media = Good luck!
hahahahah (y)
Great WBF guys, thanks! I really like the recommendation to mix up the text used social posts, rather than sticking to the dreadful Title + Link + Via/Mention formula, which is just flat out lazy. I like to extract key points/quotes from the article/post and include that in the social share and then test to see which post got the most relevant mileage.
Quick question regarding sharing others' content vs. sharing your own. What do you think is a good ratio or does it even matter? For example, right now I'm sharing about 10 posts from other sites for every one post from our own site. Am I diluting my own content by sharing too much from others?
Thanks for the comment and the tweet Syed - a lot of people will give you a rule of thumb about ratios of other people's content vs your own to share. The easy answer is to say - test it and see what works for you. :) If you vary that ratio from 5:2 vs 10:2 or 20:2 does it have an impact on how much love your own content gets?
10 seems like a lot for a regular Joe (or Syed), but then again, maybe not. If you're actually curating and engaged and delivering value and getting the kind of results you want - then it's working for you.
Excellent WBF Ben!! I loved it....I will expect Hugh traffic changes with this. Otherwise will check whatever you test and useful research in your next WBF...LOL
Great video, especially on the buttons.
Great tutorial video, thanks a lot for sharing this. Lots of familiar ground, and a few nice examples to take away.
Maybe one day, the marketing team i work alongside will break out from just printing 2000 flyers for £80 books, and actually try something exciting!
Thank you Ben & Brian sharing awesome video. Content is the key asset, we have to optimize it in well manner and make it more attractive so it can cater audience. I have also posted an article on how to amplify content marketing strategy to grow business.
Nice job ! I liked the part reserved for social integration. You also highlighted the difference in behavior between the main social networks G +, Facebook, Twitter ... Thank you!
Superb article, I would recommend Jetpack for WP-based blogs, gives you amazing integration with the besy social networks out there. Great work, thanks again.
This makes a lot of sense and it's touch because i take a lot of time for my blog posts and pages and they get some action then…nothing lol, thanks for more tips and advice
It's not always about the promotion in Facebook and Adwords
In my blogs dont promote all the time in Facebook and Adwords
Usinga good on-page seo and build a good and strong links + use of good SEO Plugins such as WordPress SEO - Yoast cane do a wonderful job.
But the announcement on Facebook and Adwords remains well and is very useful in all the time and comes with good results for Affiliate marketers .
One person at a time on Whiteboard Friday unless they're a world renowned traveling duet. It was just distracting. The whole time I felt like I was trying to get in on a private conversation.
Felt the same thing! I also believe you can get more out of the session, if the person is looking at the camera..
Nonetheless thanks for the information! It was great to get other people posting and sharing their knowledge and experience!
can't say that I disagree with either one of you. :) That was the opp so we took it. Thanks for putting up with two of us!
Thanks for great article
Thanks Ben & Brian for sharing the two most important direction of modern SEO. Yeah, Content and Social interaction is gonna the heart of SEO. I also agreed with your Brian to Boost a Facebook post is not good because you shouldn't encourage people to like your post who doesn't belong to your industry!
Great white board Friday; Creating content is challenging task but if you are not planning to promote it effectively than you will never get result. You both explain some great ways to amplifying content, Mostly don't invest in Paid social ads to promote their content but i think the best way to promote content is to run Facebook and twitter ads.
Edited -
Just used Hootsuite and its a great social media management platform. Highly recommended guys!
I would suggest to add from time to time new content to your posts. Google likes that and you can promote your article as "updated" or "new edition". The MOZ SEO Beginners guide is a great example of that.
Great work #wbf guys. The presentation has been beautifully complied. Will definitely have a look at Twitter cards and Hootsuite. Maybe, I will even implement Twitter Cards pretty soon.
@Ben thanks for sharing the post and advice.@Chase Buckner. I too tested Outbrain but found out that the bounce rate was pretty high.
Interesting Whiteboard guys!
Although you may want to read this recent news article before considering using Outbrain: https://www.thedrum.com/news/2014/06/18/asa-rules-against-native-ad-recommended-links-promotion-publisher-website
Thanks for the link. I hadn't seen this article yet. Brian talked a little about Outbrain in an earlier comment (https://moz.com/blog/tips-and-tactics-for-amplifying-your-content-whiteboard-friday#comment-290047). Definitely don't recommend leaning too hard on / counting on one channel - we've seen over & over again how that can come back to bite you. Looks like Outbrain has a big challenge ahead.
Hi its a very informative post Ben & Brian thank man hoping to C some more like this keep up the good work.
Nice gender stereotyping here, Moz. Good to know that women like shopping and pretty pictures while men are interested in business.
If there's stats to prove that, then it seems fire has already met smoke.