A PageRank layman recently asked me how Google decides what site gets what ranking. Rather than bore him with technical tidbits from last decade's abstract, I thought I could better express the concept through a medium we can all appreciate: celebrities.
The metaphor is a simple one: PageRank is all about the quantity and quality of inbound links, right? Well, the value of a celebrity is often defined by the quantity and quality of people interested in that individual. As you read on, understand that when we talk about people "linking" to celebrities, we're talking about fans trampling other fans to get a candid photo, or people constantly asking them for money or trying to book them on their crappy talkshow... the more interest the celeb generates, the higher their PageRank equivalent. If you have a beef with the selections, or want to fill in the gaps, you know what to do.
There's no argument here – The Pope is a PR10. He doesn't report the news, he makes it. He doesn't ask for favors, he pardons sinners. He doesn't express his linkage to any particular individual or company, and yet the most powerful people in the world would be happy to kneel in front of him at a moment's notice. Nearly every human being on this planet loves him, respects him, or has some sort of agenda against him. In some form, he's been around for centuries, and he's been the authority on one of the world's most prominent religions for that entire period. There is no one else like him... he's the friggin' Pope.
Jay-Z is a PR8 because of two words: persistence and transcendence. He's been in the public eye for nearly 20 years, and has been grinding his way to the top the entire time. Starting from nothing and slowly building natural public attention and linkage over two decades is pretty much Google gold, and anyone as persistent as Jay-Z is will see similar results. But it's not just hard work that gets him to a PR8… it's the fact that he has moved beyond the bounds of music, developing linkage in other arenas. Just think of all the subdomains Jay-Z has: there's Jay-Z/clothing, Jay-Z/record label, Jay-Z/vodka, Jay-Z/sports team owner, Jay-Z/Beyonce... the list goes on, and each subdomain carries with it another huge chunk of link juice (some of which, like the sports team owner aspect and Beyonce aspect, involve other high-profile people whose linkage to Jay-Z is highly respected by Google – after all, if millions of people are linking to Beyonce, and Beyonce is linked to Jay-Z, then surely some portion of Beyonce's linkers have an interest in Jay-Z as well).
Anne Hathaway makes for a great PR5. She's got a lot of appeal and her name is very well-known nowadays, but most of her fan base consists of teeny bopper nobodies and disgusting old men like me. Both of those stereotypical "linkers" are the types to latch onto any passing fancy on the web that amuses them at the time, which means their linkage to Miss Hathaway doesn't impress Google all that much. A lot of people love her... just no one who matters. P.S.: Anne, if you're reading this, I didn't mean all those things. You'll always be a 10 in my book. Also, Anne, if you're reading this, please please please go out with me. Give me just one chance, and if it's not the most fun date you've ever been on, just let me know and I promise I'll untie you.
Remember Willie Aames? No? Well now you know why he's a PR3. He's useless to 99% of the population, but still, you have to respect the fact that if he sat down in a bar, at least one person would say, "Holy crap it's Buddy Lembeck!!" And that makes him a better man than you or I, as far as Google is concerned.
If there were any justice in the world, Paris would be a PR0. How can this be, you ask? She’s known all over the country, from redneck town A to redneck town Z... surely she has some juice with Google? But my friends, have you forgotten about the repercussions of link buying? Paris has made her name by whoring her soul out to anyone with a camera or a microphone – she has blatantly attempted to gain popularity by trading her ability to keep the paparazzi employed for the public's continued attention and linkage. This is a no-no for Google, and with good reason: if you could increase your PageRank simply by being the biggest slut on the block, then we'd end up with a ranking system that rewards desperation for attention, rather than rewarding deserved attention. Google succeeds where Entertainment Tonight fails, and thanks to that, the web is a bit more decent.
Great post.
Maybe SeoMoz needs a 'What page rank are you?' quiz. Thats bound to bring in the traffic. :)
Who is Willie Aames? Maybe its time for some imdb action.
Charles in charge
Of our days and our nights
Charles in charge
Of our wrongs and our rights
I want Charles in charge of meeeeeeeeeee
Jay-Z coming right after the Pope??? No offence, but you Americans are crazy ;)
I must agree with Ann! Maybe someone like Carl Lewis would have been a better choice : great sportsman, olympic games gold medalist, been there for 20 years,...
Great post though!
True, he's been around forever, but Carl Lewis isn't getting many links these days. High trust, but lower relevance.
Plus, there was the whole national anthem thing. My editorial flag would have gone up over that.
Ann -
I agree with you on Jay-Z. I just love the concept though.
Hell. even with Paris Hilton I think he was generous. Total spam scraper whore with no original content. Clearly she should have been delisted altogether.
double post... dun dun duuuunnnnn.
Ann, I don't listen to him myself... but I did when I was younger, and if you look at his career (the plateaus he's reached and the branches he's sprouted), he's as good an example as any to make a case for a website that starts from nothing, and in 8 or 9 years has built itself up to be an authoritative domain on multiple topics. I'd liken him to the chronological progress of Mozilla.org (PR9), though with significantly less market penetration potential - hence the 8 in my book.
Big thumbs up for working Buddy Lembeck into a post. That's the best thing I've seen/read in weeks.
Also for the self-deprecating stalker talk. Well done, sir.
Rick Astley would have really high PR. He was making link bait videos in the 1980's. He was just 20+ years early! :)
Brilliant!
Now, I wonder when the Vatican will release PopeRank?
Would be interesting to correlate that against PageRank...then we'd really know whether Google practices "Do no evil." ;)
{wow, I'm surely going to hell for that one}
PopeRank, I love it! Given our secular society, I would imagine people would still be more concerned with their PageRank, though...
I really love this post....especially the horrendous picture of Ms. Hilton. Thumbs up for that.
But shouldn't there be an Oprah level, maybe 9 since we couldn't possibly put her above the Pope....but the type where everything they touch turns to gold. lol! Loved it!
That picture of Paris Hilton is from the movie House of Wax. I dragged my boyfriend to see it because I love crappy horror movies, and no joke, we were the only people in the theater about five days after it was released.
I would've replaced "friggin'" with the real thing, but then I would have been thumbed down a zillion times for it so . . . good judgement call.
We need a list of celebrity 301 redirects:
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_URI} !^Michael Jackson$RewriteRule ^(.*)$R. Kelly$1 [R=302,L]
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_URI} !^Barry Bonds$RewriteRule ^(.*)$Roger Clemens$1 [R=301,L]
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_URI} !^O.J. Simpson$RewriteRule ^(.*)$George W. Bush$1 [R=301,L]
We need some more! ;-)
Brent D. Payne
niiiice Brent!
For proving yet again that original content is king - I give you a
Nice work Mitch. You could have a field day with this concept.
Awesome! Thanks Sean
damn goood :P
by the way britney can be an example of PAGERANK DECREMENT
;)
This is the most creative and accurate look at PR I've seen in a long time. MAJOR bonus points for the ability to show this to other people outside of SEO and it make sense. Dang this is good!
Thumbs up just for the awful paris image.
Fisrt psot!!!111!!!!!
Unfortunately, Paris can't get out of PageRank Zero just by calling home and crying "aww this sucks" and applying "The Secret."
Innovative post, Mitch.
As a sometimes teacher, I think it is all about finding analogies in order to relate information in an effective way.
"I can teach Japanese to a chimp in 46 hours. You just have to find a way to relate the material." - Rubin from Road Trip
Entertaining and good work
Thanks... I'm always trying to create analogies for SEO, because there's so much of it that clients could grasp if it was explained to them in layman's terms. SEO has such close ties to traditional small business development that I've found it beneficial to do things like this from time to time in order to get my clients on the same page.
I love it. I am going to use this only I am going to change some of the stars depending on who I am talking to. The Pope is great for the top. His Pope-ness has longevity and he makes news even when he doesn't want to. Nobody can argue with that. And in all worlds Paris is the bottom. She means zero on so many levels.
Nice job.
Oh this is so good, great work!
Buddy Lembeck's right up there with Boner Stabbone ;)
But is there any correlation between celebrity PR and ease of being hacked?
And if a celebrity dies ..can you 301 him or her?
and should we factor in ease of access or upload time?
Probably lots more analogies ...great post by the way
But you don't see the disadvantages of such a celebrity-PR-system, e.g. the great joe cocker would get banned for duplicate content ;-)
great post mike!
Paris Hilton deserve Page Rank 0. Google punish her for bad behavior :)
Did anyone else catch that? lol
Wonderfully fun post!
From a Sports angle People who would warrant PR0's for whoring their legacy and downstairs manhood for the sake of perfermance enhancing include...
Barry Bonds-PR0
Roger Clemens-PR0
Sammy Sosa-PR0
Mark McGuire-PR0
Pete Rose-PR2- He's just a major liar and hustler...all of his many records are real!
George W. Bush- PR1- No WMD's in Iraq = Spammer. Even tho he has the Lowest approval rating in history-he gets a PR1 because he is still the president...somehow
So funny, all of those PR0 names - I have never heard of any of them.
I'm in the UK. Their 'fame' has not spread very far. :-)
They are American Baseball players who used steriods to gain records, except for Pete Rose...
I lived in England for about 4 months and if you started naming famous cricket players or even football (Soccer to us) players with PR0, you would have me stumped
*** ... cricket players ... ... stumped ... ***
LOL
Thanks so much for such an entertaining and effective post. I will try to use this for inspiration the next time I get too technical and see the person I am talking to start to fall asleep.
Guess I'm somewhere between Paris and Willie!
Cute stuff!
Brilliant!!!!
Thought this post was hilarious and kept me reading! A very unconventional, but effective way to explain the Google pagerank system - even to the experienced !! I'll be explaining this one to my business partner using your terms and giving you all the credit. Well done sir!
A phenomenal post, Mitch. Creative, and very accurate. I might throw Tiger Woods up there as a PR9...someone who everyone likes and who is going to accrue almost as many links in the next 8 months even without putting out any new content.
I was actually going to put Tiger Woods there at first David... but then, what's a good blog post without a bit of controversy?
I'll even go as far as to say this is one of the best posts I've ever seen (and I've read a few). Both educational AND entertaining (I love some of the comments too; "Can you 301 a celebrity?").
I agree with HannahS, there should be a Multiple-Thumbs-Up button ;)
Celebrity culture comes to SEO. It was a matter of time :) Nice post.
!!!
one of my favorite posts in a while. Totally entertaining.
This is brilliant - particularly nice work on Ms Hilton. I suppose you could go a step further and add Paris to Google Webmaster Tools...She'd get a long list of all the bad or just plain stupid things she'd done in her life that Google knows about and get a chance to try to redeem herself.
Great Post! *thumbs up*. I understood it straight away! *throws away the Pagerank Maths book*
I love posts like this - if only we could give multiple thumbs :)
This makes my top ten favourite SEOmoz posts ever list. Awesome stuff!
Mike,
Reading your post has brought me closer to understanding PR better than anything I have read this year.
[reminder to self: read more stuff...]
GR8 job!
hehe, i really like paris hilton section.
good work!
301 paris hilton and willie aames?
Why I think that'd be possible...
Also Ms Hilton would deserve an honourary mention of Googles Trust Rank - what with her alternative videos "one night with paris" she'd be getting an awful lot of links from disreputable sights (and no not perezhiltion) and thus pushing her ho ass down (think i'm too english to say that with a straight face!)
Plus the number of Paris blonde cyborg clones (Richie, the otherone etc) would lead to a bit of a duplicate content problem as well!
just a great one! thumbs up!
You had me at Buddy Lembeck.
Great idea for a post!
"There is no one else like him... he's the friggin' Pope."
You have to perform 100 Hail Mary's for that blasphemy :.)
Damn I love a good metaphor.
Nice work, dude.
PR: wait... I: wait... L: wait... LD: wait... I: wait...wait... C: wait... SD: wait...
Pretty good stuff.
Would have to agree with quite a few people above. Jay-Z is the wrong person for an 8. If someone is an 8, people like my mom or non-US friends should recognize the name.
Michael Jordan or Oprah as already mentioned would probably work.