Tons and tons of interesting news to report from the last couple weeks, and rather than just report, I'm going to go ahead and give my opinions, too.
- Search Engine Popularity Ratings - No one really knows what the search engine market share is, not Comscore, not Neilsen, not Hitwise. If they really managed data of the demographic variety and quality that they claim, the figures wouldn't be as different as they are. Actually, I take back my initial statement - Yahoo!, News Corp, Hearst and other major media giants that control dozens of unique, high-volume domains, probably have a better sense of which engines control what percentages of searches. I really don't see why the engines don't publicize their numbers of unique visitors and unique searches each month - that data would help them sell ads and grow publicity - I don't know what the downside is.
- Eyetracking and Article Design - Aaron posted about this on Monday and it's got me thinking - if better content organization yields less time on page but greater recall and branding, the metrics we typically think about for measuring success may be a bit backwards. When I see that the average user spends only 70 seconds reading an SEOmoz post, I think - we need to be more interesting and more targeted with our blogs. I don't think - wow, our content is really well organized and laid out. Jakob's study would suggest that if we featured better layout, we'd actually be seeing "worse" metrics, with better results.
- PPC & SEO Work Better Together - This just sucks because now I need to go back and re-learn PPC. I used to be great at it 3 years ago, but the landscape has changed completely, and it looks like the "extra" visibility from having both a top PPC ad and top organic placement is truly worth the effort. Maybe I can just stick Rebecca on it :)
- Andy's SEM Scholarship is Back - It made a huge start out of last year's winner, Ben Wills, and although he's given up blogging, you'll still see him with gaggles of fans at conferences (including yours truly). This year might be a bit tougher - there's only a single round of article submissions, but, on the plus side, the value of the prizes is ~$10,000 and includes a ton of good stuff. And yes, I'm judging again this year :)
- Googlebombing Algo Evidence - Normally, I believe Matt Cutts and team when they say that their anti-Googlebombing algo update is completely automated and doesn't manually target phrases... But, if that's the case, shouldn't it be filtering result #3 for this search (Oswald Cobblepot)? If any anti-anchor-text-bombing algo existed, it should really catch that one (screencap below in case they do change it quickly):
For those wondering why this exists, it's just a practical joke that Matt played on Rebecca - internal office humor stuff. And yes, we're total geeks for ranking stuff at Google in our spare time just to mess with our friends. - Newspapers are Dead - I'm linking to Lisa Barone here, because she does the best job covering the issue. My personal take is similar - newspapers and traditional media may lose some ground, but even if Robert Scoble's kids won't be scubscribing to them, there's too much of an infrastructure that provides true value to the world for the entire media publishing world to collapse. The systems that newspapers have built in relationships, partnerships, access, etc. are unachievable by bloggers (unless they start organizing into news-media like entities).
- Neil Patel Bitch Slaps Calcanis - Many thanks to Todd for writing that; I've always wanted to put that in the title of a blog post, and linking to it just makes me feel that much better. The truth about SEO is that the search engines have preferences - they're machines, running on automated algorithms and when you have a lot of experience working with them, you develop a really good idea of what works and what doesn't. There's no black magic, here, it's just like any other skill - experienced chefs know when a steak is ready from the smell and a finger on top of the meat, great plumbers can tell what's wrong just by listening to your pipes drain water and SEOs, the good ones, can diagnose and fix/help ranking issues in much the same way (although our profession also requires a massive dose of marketing-savvy, too).
- Google Taking On European Spam - There are really three different posts and a whole slew of actions that indicate this is a major focal point for Google. First, there's Viktor Nebehaj talking about Eastern Europe, then there's Stefanie (whom I just met for the first time in Munich - terrific gal) updating us on spam reporting and finally, there's Matt Cutts talking about all the Google spam folks who are spreading out to Dublin (Brian White in particular). It's a sign of the times - Google feels like they have some very good solutions for US-based spam, and they've dealt with the 20% that provided 80% of the problem. Now, they're exporting those solutions to Europe. I think there's more than a few notable black hats that Google's Dublin team is specifically gunning for, which has to be a scary feeling.
- Digg's Comments Working Against Them - We all know this, but Digg's comment systems currently rewards the meanest, nastiest folks who can still be funny. The ascerbicly harsh and destructive comments get the most up votes and visibility. I'm with Neil in agreeing that the Slashdot system makes a lot of sense - have karma points for users and don't make the comments marked "funny" count towards these. This will build up a much more professional and respectable community of commenters (hopefully, unless it's already too late). BTW - Just wanted to take this opportunity to thank the SEOmoz commenting community - it's amazing that the quality of discussions in this blog are so consistently positive and valuable.
- Going Viral on Digg Part II - Daniel Tynski is at it again, spilling loads of great ideas and strategies for getting Dugg (and appealing to other linkbait portals, too).
That's all for today.. except wait! For those who might be interested in learning more about SEOmoz internal decisions and our business model and the premium membership, I did a podcast last week with Eric Enge that's now up on his site (there's also a transcript for those who'd prefer to read).
Neil Patel Bitch Slaps Calcanis
Best headline all week, I laughed so hard I almost sharted.
After recently getting burned in what I thought was a friendly comment exchange, I've decided to reel my commenting right back in (that anouncement alone might get me enough thumbs to outweigh the 200% increase in down thumbs the little spat got me).
Most of the time though it is a pleasure to take part in such thoughtful, adult conversations.
Ciaran,
Please don't worry about it, it was only that guy that was thumbing you down. Everyone else was thumbing HIM down!! Please don't refrain from commenting because of him. It was his first time at commenting, only to be rude. That says alot about him. If he reads this I will probably get the same treatment, but you know what, I'll just ignore it.
You seen how many thumbs down I've got? Or Rebecca? Or Rand?
Yes but I'm one of those sad types who wants everyone to like me!
Aww :) For being that cute, I just thumbed you up
I feel a Scrubs comment coming on...
"Well, I figure with her being ridiculously book-smart to the point where she has almost no interpersonal skills and you being warm and cuddly as an unpotty-trained labradoodle and about as useful in high-stress medical situations as an unpotty-trained labradoodle, together the two of you would make one barely passable doctor... slash labradoodle."
Gotta love Scrubs. I may have to rename one of my blogs labradoodle!
Sharp eyes to pull together the Europe stuff, but it's not just Europe where we're ramping up our communication. I keep trying to free up a couple hours to talk about it more. Glad you met Stefanie, by the way!
On the googlebomb stuff, I believe we said that it was designed to be very limited in terms of scope and impact.
"I really don't see why the engines don't publicize their numbers of unique visitors and unique searches each month - that data would help them sell ads and grow publicity - I don't know what the downside is."
I can think of a reason or two. Practice your ability to put yourself in a search engine's shoes. :)
See Ciaran, I just got my first thumbs down!! Oh well...
Yep - they just keep on coming!
;)
We do have thumb monitoring systems and the pattern I see with thumbs down on this thread look a bit bizarre. When we do see folks thumbing down for no particular reason, or for apparently personal reasons, rather than content-related ones, much like Google, we can pull a person's thumb power. I was hoping it wouldn't come up, though...
Rand will you be posting data on everyone's thumb patterns so we can all reverse engineer the algorithm? I do hope you know I'm joking.
Up until seeing the comments on that other thread I had never given anyone here a thumbs down and had no intention of ever giving one either. But insulting other people for no reason is uncalled for. It adds nothing to the discussion and serves no purpose.
"thumb power", I love it =)
But yeah it seems to be alot of thumbing down for reasons other than content. The post Cieran was referring too was just ridiculous with regards to thumbing down. Really don't think Cieran deserved those thumbs down, he was even trying to be nice to the guy and he took it the wrong way.
Anyway, I loved Todd's post about Neil Patel proving Jason wrong. Neil seems like such a cool guy, instead of saying "you're wrong you idiot" he says you are wrong and i'll show you why. As Ali G would put it "RESPECT, aiiiiiii!"
How much fun can you have with a thumb!?
Lisadit really does know her stuff and it's a sad day to see her receive a thumbs down! I've counter-thumbed with an upward to comensate.
Can the MOZ team introduce a Fonzerelli (AKA the Fonz) 'two-thumbs' for ultra cool posts in the future? Perhaps with an on-click audio file 'eeeeiiiiiiiiiii'?
We all loves ya - and you only have one thumb down. I got mine for my blog on my very first conference apperance.
And I was the highest rated speaker there - no pleasing some *winks*
Maybe I should blog about my article...?
Google has thumbs?
;)
Why does Google pwn all other engines? Opposable thumbs :)
Google is the monkey in 2001: Space Oddyssey that picks up the stick and beats the crap out of the other monkeys!
I thought this was supposed to be a state secret :P
That's Rand off of Matt Cutts' Xmas card list!
I meant our thumb powers... but Rand falls on and off of Matt C's Christmas card list about once daily, doesn't he?!
It is a little sad to see the power of the thumbs has to be monitored.
I think it is great fun and I've enjoyed seeing myself thumb my way to the top 60 on the board.
Mind... it does speak volumes for what I do on my breaks...
After our crash and burn experiment with AdWords, I've been wanting to get more experienced in PPC. I just need the time to sit down and study it, damnit!
Oh, and by the way, Oswald Cobblepot is also known as the Penguin, and since Matt harbors an unhealthy obsession with Batman Returns, that's why I'm ranking for that particular term. Oh well, could be worse...at least my nose isn't gushing blood...
Good to hear. After seeing Google result #4, I knew the question would surface.
hey Rebecca =)
Pay Per Click can be super exciting, it's like your own little stockmarket. I get so excited when I see the CTR go up, the avg CPC go down and my avg position rise. It's all in the CTR baby! No seriously it's much more to it that that. Google AdWords has changed so much in the last year and the improvements are massive. Like being able to test several ads at once....ok might not seem like much but man was testing ads a nightmare before. As for Yahoo (overture)...we are still waiting for the new platform to be realeased in the UK. It better be good.
I do PPC for all my clients as well as SEO, and won't ever do SEO without also implementing web analytics (I'm like Rand, a big "analytics whore"). If you need any help and tips with your PPC campaigns let me know =)
Hey, how about sharing your tips/experiences with everyone via a YOUmoz post?
After that 2 day emetrics summit, web analytics will never look the same to me again..
And I thought *I* was geeky! That Nokia guy made me feel totally normal - THANKS DUDE!
Rebecca, can I recommend .... https://www.seomoz.org/blog/17-most-common-ppc-mistakes
-web-marketers-make
With PPC advertising, just like SEO it's all about testing different stuff. There are a lot of good information at the Adwords blog. Unfortunately there are not a lot of strictly PPC blogs (something I wanted to start).
Thanks, Igor :)
Rand, I like this format better - it gives me a better idea of whether or not I should click to read the original post. Sometimes there's just not enough hours in a day to read everything I'd like to.
Managing SEO and PPC at the same time... hard thing to do right. I know from experience... :(
Glad you liked it Bob - it seriously PAINS me to even say the guy's name and give him any more attention, though it was really nice to see Neil at least attempt to prove the point (though we should have known it would fall on deaf ignorant ears).
What really pisses me off is that he takes some free consulting that will no doubt increase his search traffic, and then acts like an ambivalent asshole about it. I don't think I could overemphasize what a douchebag I think this guy is. It's catch 22 though, because it pisses me off every time I catch myself wasting time ranting about his douchebagary.
I too was intrigued by MediaPost's article on PPC & SEO. This is something I have been preaching for a long time. It's always good when you have a reputable source to fall back on and quote.
I had been following the Neil / JC challenge for a bit, glad to see he pulled through with so few methods. Score, one for the good guys!
I think Calacanis' MO may well be to be the biggest asshole known to SEO. He's making himself linkbait.
And we're falling for it.
Controversial topic baiting has long been played. It's hard for some to keep quite when others attack them personally or something they are passionate about.
He is killing his Online rep though. I am sure whatever he gained in links will be countered by crappy online reputation.
You make a good point. However, some people thrive on being the bad guy... who knows why JC says and does these things!
You sure? He makes a lot of noise, but just think for a minute:
1) He tells the SEO industry they can suck ass through a straw as far as he's concerned
2) Someone, like Neil maybe, takes him up and says "ok, I'll prove it to you"
3) Jason turns round and appologises and becomes SEO's biggest supporter. Everyone loves him
Me? Cinical? Never...
(sidenote: he's also lousy at wording things. He can mean one thing, but come across as saying something else, because he doesn't put it across it right)
I feel like this is something we could hypothesise about all day...
I've been wondering why people keep linking to him and commenting about what he says. He seems so obvious about using attack hooks. One thing he's teaching me is that the seo community is the most baitable community there is.
Google bombing is alive and well out in the provinces. The Italian government recently presented the much derided national portal which is suppose to promote Italian turism. It was a pet project of a minister in the former government. The multilingual portal, italia.it, is currently the number one result for "merda", at least from where I'm sitting, in both English and Italian language results. To the best of my knowledge, the portal does not publicize the "merda" tourists ("e non" as they say in Italiano) have to step through on the pavement/sidewalks of Milan, Rome and the other great Italian cities. I suspect the ranking is due to off-site factors....
I'm working on the assumption that the anti-Google bombing algorithm hamsters are on a break.
new googlebomb, go and try it with an obvious negative phrase like sucks and see what happens ... my favorite is disney or yahoo ranking for "leave"
Looks like "leave" is the new "exit". Time to update those powerpoint slides :P
Cool, does that mean we just googlebomb on a smaller scale, or perhaps we make sure we're not aggressively accumulating links in a short space of time?