Editor's note This post has been updated with new data as of 9/28/16. We'll continue to update as the dust settles and we get a clearer picture of Penguin 4.0's impact.
For almost two years (707 days, to be precise), one question has dominated the SEO conversation: “When will Google update Penguin?” Friday, we finally got the answer. Google announced that a Penguin update is rolling out and that Penguin is now operating in real-time.
September has been a very volatile month for the SERPs (more on that later in the post), but here’s what we’re seeing in MozCast for the past two weeks, including last night:
At 113°F, September 27th was the 2nd-hottest day in MozCast history, and we've seen a steady ramp-up since Google's announcement on September 23. Google has suggested that the impact of Penguin 4.0 could take time, as they re-crawl the entire web, especially deep links. I was initially skeptical of this idea, but the data suggest that this may be exactly what is happening. We'll know more over the coming days.
What happened in September?
September has been the most volatile month for SERPs since I started tracking temperatures in April of 2012 (just a couple of weeks before Penguin 1.0). To the best of my knowledge at this time, the volatility during early-to-mid September was not due to the Penguin 4.0 roll-out.
There are no official statements (currently) about other updates, but we’re aware of two things. First, many local SEOs saw major shifts around September 1st, when MozCast tracked a high of 108°F. This has been dubbed the Possum Update, and reports are that local pack URLs also moved substantially (MozCast does not track this data). We did see an overall drop in local pack presence in our data set on that day (about 7.3% day-over-day).
Second, between September 13th and 14th there was a massive drop in SERPs with image (vertical) results on page 1 in our data set. This caused substantial volatility, as image results occupy an organic position and so those SERPs got an extra organic result on page 1. The temperature that day was 111°F. Here’s the two-week graph of SERPs with image results on page 1:
SERPs with images in our data set dropped 49% overnight and have not recovered. I've hand-checked dozens of these results and have verified the drop. In some cases, images moved to deeper pages. It's unclear if other vertical/universal results were affected.
Were you affected by Penguin 4.0?
I've often said that measuring algorithm flux is like tracking the unemployment rate. It's interesting to the economy at large if the rate is 5% or 6%, but ultimately you either have a job or you don't. If you were hit by an algorithm update, it's little comfort that the MozCast temperature was low on that day.
Hopefully, if you were impacted by Penguin in the past and have made changes, those changes have been rewarded (or soon will be). The good news is that, now that Penguin is real-time, we shouldn't have to wait another two years for a major refresh.
As soon as the news was announced, my immediate reaction was "has it happened has it happened has it happened?", checking a client of mine who was affected - and is awaiting a recovery - but not seeing any immediate adjustment. But then I saw this from Eric Enge's Twitter:
"Just clarified a key point about #penguin with @methode: impact will only be felt as Google completes a recrawl of the web" - source
...So it'll be interesting to see what the next few hours/days/weeks/months holds and hearing news of recoveries.
My gut feeling is that the bulk of the impact will happen in days, not weeks, because that's what history suggests. Google often implies long roll-outs to keep us guessing, IMO. I will update the data/post over the next few days, though, if anything happens. Unfortunately, so much has happened in September that it can be hard to separate all of the things going on. The further we get from the launch date, the tougher it will be to know whether a temperature spike is Penguin or something new.
I agree. I also have a local (non-US) client awaiting recovery on a main keyword/landing page, but no improvement yet. However, starting September 18, a lot of keywords related to the main one (but with different landing pages) have greatly improved, with jumps of 20-30 positions straight to top 10 in some cases. Not sure if that's related.
100% agree, Dr Pete. If I was Google, I would certainly make the ranking changes subtle and gradual rather than drastic. I think they learned their lesson from the first Panda/Penguin updates that it's not beneficial to anger everyone and turn the spotlight on themselves- better to obfuscate and roll out multiple updates at once and have the changes take affect slowly. Hench John's "good luck with that" comment. It's better for companies to holistically determine that they need to spend more on SEM rather than forcing/shocking them into it.
If that's the case then it will take some time to see the full affect of this update. I guess
Soooooo.... did they recover. Has anyone seen any recovery case studies?
The update was pending for long, and Google might be again looking to do nothing less than a re-shuffle of ranks. I agree with Dr. Peter J. Meyers , we also expect the impact to visible real soon.
Though our clients are pretty well, we are keeping our fingers crossed, as our experience suggests you can't predict how google understands your work till you have analyzed the actual results.
Google will no longer confirm Penguin update
Google also said with this update, it will no longer confirm future Penguin updates. That actually means, we will have to study and understand the changes; and not expect Google to keep updating about the future Penguine based updates on SERPs.
Thanks,
Vijay
Hi Everyone,
In the google blog it mentions that "changes will be visible much faster, typically taking effect shortly after we recrawl and reindex a page". Did anyone submit the website in Google Search Console after this announcement? Should we?
Good question.....any answer? =)
Still is soon but I think Penguin is going to "reorder" the SERPs slowly, taking in account what Google said about it being more "granular". Now impact page-by-page? if you were penalized, you will be rewarded now page-by-page?
What do you think?
Nice to see you here too, soon i´ll have a class with you. As you say it´s soon to see, in my case i´m kind of paranoid with linkbuild at the point of stopping it.
I am more interested in the negative SEO aspect.
Hi Dr. Peter,
Thanks for sharing Latest Penguin update.
Finally Google announced Penguin 4.0 update and given its new real-time nature.
On this update Penguin becomes more page-specific, not site-wide only and Google will no longer confirm Penguin update. Penguin 4.0, Google would not give a specific number of the percentage of queries it impacted, mostly because the update is constantly happening and the percentage will constantly be changing.
Not seeing anything major yet in the UK for the 50 or so clients / verticals we track. September has seen a lot of change and some quite major reshuffling in many of the verticals but since Friday very little. I tend to agree that most of the impact will likely take days rather than weeks (80% days and final 20% weeks?) but as of yet it's pretty uninteresting.
One thing I have not yet seen discussed is how this effects folks that are struggling under an algorithmic penalty or dampening of results as such. We have a few we are watching who have really cleaned up their act and are generally top tier businesses being outranked by two bit players in industries that they should be sitting atop of the pile for if search mapped to the real world. Yet, as of today there seems little movement.
If we look at certain sites that we believed to be labouring under an algorithmic penalty then the dodgy links are cleaned up, disavowed and in many cases actually just don't exist any longer. How does Google deal with this? How can these links be assessed in real time if they are no longer there? Are they hitting the reset on these historical factors or is that also somehow being worked through bit by bit. A lot of the pre penguin 1.0 web simply does not exist any longer as there is no benefit to maintaining it.
Given the way this has worked historically with some form of minus adjustment seemingly rolled out overnight after they have done the analysis behind the scenes how do they remove that and then review everything for these new sites? Could the carnage of early September be the removal of those adjustments whilst they are now recrawling and recalculating everything real time? Is the entire link graph just going to be reassessed as they go?
I am none the wiser but given that we are not seeing any improvement from folks where we thought it was all but certain or a drop for other folks that have been going to town with garbage SEO for a couple of years it's looking more like a lame duck than an angry penguin at this point - but I do have faith. :)
I also find myself wondering if the engineering challenge was to get this whole element real time maybe they can now turn up or down the aggression for certain factors relatively easily.
We can only wonder what the next two weeks will bring!
Cheers
Marcus
Great post Marcus,
I too am really curious about how they transfer from the old filter into the new real time algo is supposed to work. As we see no particular effect yet, one might assume that a full "re crawl" of the web, as quoted by
Eric Enge @stonetemple Sep 23
Just clarified a key point about #penguin with @methode: impact will only be felt as Google completes a recrawl of the web
So, question remains... what is really a "completed recrawl of the web"?
Thanks for sharing the statistical view about the impact of Penguin update. It's far better reading such an informative article than plugging out ears after rumors. However, I also felt a kind of celerity in overall Google activities since a month or so.
In the starting of Sep'16, there were too many structured data errors reported by Webmasters which were later told to be condoned on Google forums as null and void. Still, people are grumbling about it.
Then, came out the significant updates in both G+ and GA tools which I would state as a welcome change. And finally, the Penguin entered into the climax. I wish the latest of it could treat the real ailment what it is meant for, instead of inflicting unwarranted fears.
Anyways, reading such an inquisitive article makes people like us more informed and directs to step in the right direction. Thanks.
Since reading I've been checking all my sites like a kid at Christmas, its a little sad how exciting some of the change could be, the other side of the coin is how it (SERPs) is going to change things going forward. Busy month!
Agree...!!! It is a busy month :( :|
Have not seen wild fluctuations in the last few days for clients' site. Had a site that I was in talks with that got hit for a few big keywords around Sep 1-3, which doesn't seem to be in your range above. Might have been part of a early rolling Penguin update? Not much transparency from Google so pretty hard to tell!
It's not in the graph, but there was a big update around September 1st, that seems tied to local (dubbed the "Possum" update). I think it had implications beyond just local.
One of My Site Suddenly lose 25% traffic from 10th of Aug and again major drop in traffic on Sep 10th & 13th no idea what is happening on that time???
Hi Dr. Peter J. Meyers
Nice article.I think now is the time to talk about this real-time penguin changes and on and on penalizing.On of them was group penalizing that we suffered from it since September 1st.I am waiting for that discussion on MOZ.What are Group Penalizing and how we can avoid it!
Thanks man.
Hello all. Maybe someone know...Penguin 4 is finally done or still rolling? Thanks.
Hi Donvil,
As far as I understood, from now on, Penguin is a continuous process. Every time a crawler indexes a page, if it discovers changes, the SERP might change too.
Definately, still rolling out...
I was surprised by this article, I thought that google penguin had already entered into force. And the 4.0 was the end of 2015. We will have to be careful with the new changes.
To be fair, it was around this time last year that they said the Penguin would march before Christmas (2015)... Then they said after Christmas (2016), so that we could get over the seasonal traffic and trends. And then they went back to saying before Christmas (2016). A year later... XD
We want bolver crazy, xd
I think Google created better oportunities for folks who like to see how far they can go...
Now you can screw up a website and make corrections if google hits you...
With the previous updates your website was screwed forever. Waiting for a next Penguin update which could take forever was not an option for most websites. Now you may be less carefull, because even if you screw it up completely, you can just disavow everything and start all over next time your website is indexed...
Right? ;)
My thoughts exactly. Also gives a lot more opportunity for testing Penguin though... FOR SCIENCE!
That's an interesting perspective. So you think that any penalites are completely eliminated by "disavowing" the links?
Not so sure, maybe there will be something like a memory of mistakes or some amount of penalization recovery allowed.
Nevertheless, it is highly probable, if abused, it will be a hidden strike algorithm.
My thought too, webshoptracker !
I personally consider the Penguin 4, a big gift to SEO. Just wanted to see more of an affect on rankings, especially those which have clearly used some pretty questionable off page. I am concerned as I have one segment of the Internet where I monitor the entire first page results for a very competitive search term. What I can share is that the #1 ranking site has a majority of links that there is no way to label other than SPAM.
Since 'Penguin' is a real-time update, it wont be making any difference within the short period of a day or two. The overall SEO process will be benefiting from ' Penguin', as SEOs failing to provide quality work can be averted.
It'll be interesting to see if Penguin now being real time will speed up the process of disavowing or re-avowing links - perhaps the lengthy review process might be dropped?
Similarly, it would be great to set up a test of how quickly Google can react if spam links are removed at their source now that it has the ability to keep up to date.
We'll later discover they actually didn't roll anything out, it was just a trick to get us to frantically begin rankings checks while they laughed at how confused we were that the update didn't seem to actually do anything we expected.
-Jake Bohall
Interesting.. on my toes checking out my sites..
This is a great post and well laid out (anything with a graph tells a story). I think that being a part of the Moz community is why being on top of the most recent news in the industry is pretty easy. I read this and then looked like an all star today at my meeting. Time will tell for those who either needed the re-index or that have ignored it.
Hi Peter,
Thanks for sharing.
I noticed that there is a major change in the pages that Google now shows in response to a query.
Although still being among the first page results, not showing exactly the query words in the meta description, now it is showing the page with more inbound links, instead of the exact response in the meta tags as it used to, these past two years.
In sum, more link factors and more semantic relations, on the other hand, less exact correlation with the title tags and meta descriptions with keywords.
I assume that the bounce rate is also playing a high role - observations done on a Real Estate in South America website.
Also, I found four PDF results! among the ten organic in the first page - observation done on Spanish results for "cursos seguridad funcional" in Google Argentina. Maybe the images drop and the PDF rises.
Any other observations in this regard?
This could well be the results of other factors that may be unrelated to Penguin. It will take some time for Google to update all the algos and I do believe that they will update .com or .co.uk first.
Hi Montse.
You are probably right, with regard to exactly which algorithm caused those changes.
From what you said, nobody has seen such abnormality in .com or .co.uk
On the other hand, due to the target market being the whole of South America, I checked each country. The only one with those very unusual 4 PDF results was Google Argentina.
In my experience, Google Argentina is one step ahead in the region, most of the time.
Maybe this explains why my site dropped 46 pages in the space of 30 minutes last week.
Well this just kind of changed my plans for the weekend... Hoping to validate an ungodly number of hours spent on link detox work over the last 2 years.
Interested to see how granular the new update truly gets (i.e. Penguin applied at the sub-domain/folder/page level vs. whole domain).
I totally agree this September is volatile month, so far there are major changes. I am in impression that in coming days SERP will reflect the real affect of Penguin 4.
But its interesting to see the upcoming Moz Cast graph.
let see how we are getting along with this,.
I am not really sure about this Penguin update. Not seeing any major changes. Probably Google was getting irritated with people asking all the time about penguin so that just posted a blog post clarifying their stance.
Hopefully, that will remove the unfair practices
One of my client a wedding photographer suffered as his site moved down from page 1 to page 1 for many keywords. It's not a penalty but seems more like some other's rankings improved leaving my client to move down the rankings
Thanks for sharing.
Thanks Dr. Peter for such valuable insights. I was so excited with this news about Penguin and with Mozcast temperature spikes, but so far not much happening to the website that was affected in 2014. Keeping my eyes on it though.
So that's what was going on in the past fortnight or so! We have definitely seen some changes and fluctuations... Should have thought of the big G!
Thanks!
Hi Peter, thanks for this great article. I haven't noticed any sort of major impact in the search rankings yet for my personal projects. Don't know if that's good news or bad news.
I think Penguin 4.0 is here with us right now and rolling out the bad and spam links, i have seen many falls & raise on my website keywords.
I guess realtime has a different meaning to most people than Google. 7 months in, and all the eveidence I can gather points to a simple change in results based on who Google want to force into PPC. There's no evidence of live anything. Looking at this thread all I can see is confusion. Nothing explaining what Google did from Google. There was no Penguin anything from what I can see. Please educate me.
So are sites getting penalised for black hat techniques any more? I have a bunch of competitors with the dodgiest link profiles overcoming my clear profile with no black hat techniques, fully optimised e-commerce website. Is Penguin 4.0 a roll-back to the old days of SEO?
The short answer is: yes. Sites are definitely still getting penalized, both algorithmically and manually. There are many link-based penalties still in play that are not Penguin. At the same time, Penguin continues to devalue links and is probably doing so more aggressively.
This, of course, doesn't mean that black-hat tactics never work or that certain industries aren't rife with them. On the other hand, I wouldn't use the new Penguin as permission to engage in spammy tactics. There are still many risks.
Could you please elaborate on "certain industries"? I'm in the tobacco business and I get the feel that the big G doesn't care much about a spammy link profile for when it comes to prohibited advertising niches.
I think it's a bit more complicated than that. The problem is that, if an entire vertical is full of people using spammy tactics, then Google has a problem. If they punish those tactics, they end up taking out everyone, and the sites behind those sites are often just as bad or worse. So, punishing spam basically hurts search quality.
This is what happened with Penguin 1.0. Google had situations where they basically penalized positions #1-#5 (for example), only to find that #6-#10, who now took the top spots, were bad quality sites, too, but just for different reasons.
So, sometimes, the question of how risky of tactics you can use isn't clear cut.
Finally, we got Google update after long time (2 years). I love Google update because it helps to remove unnecessary or misguiding websites from Google search engine results.
Can anyone tell here, what is the major change in this Google update (penguin-4) which we need to keep remember for upcoming SEO strategy.
I wish it was easier to really determine what the heck happened overall. I have local and organic results in chaos...organic has stabilized and come back, but Local is still awry.
Hoping local 'comes back'...frustrating to see searches you ranked in the Top 3 for now replaced by the same company with multiple listings. Sweet update Google...thanks for helping us out!
Fortunately or unfortunately, whatever happened to local results at the beginning of September seems to have no connection to Penguin. Hard to say if all of that will settle down.
And how do we know that? How can we actually confirm that there was no connection between them?
Thanks!
I think My client have been hit by penguin 4.0 update. All the keywords were at #2-3 on Google. But now They are 7-8 th position and some of them are 2nd,3rd page. After checking the backlinks profile I think our competitor did a reverse SEO campaign. I see many backlinks from PBN which i didnt build. Can you suggest me what should I do to get back my old rankings? Thanks In Advance.
The impact of the new, real-time Penguin, as best we know, is much different from previous Penguin algorithm updates. The new Penguin will devalue links and is more selective. You could see links lose value for specific pages, but you're not likely to see a sitewide impact that looks like a traditional penalty. If you're seeing widespread drops like this, it's possible you're dealing with a different link-based penalty or something else entirely.
If these are keywords that have been #2-3 on Google for a while, and that was not based on bad links, then it's unlikely this is the new Penguin at work.
Not sure how google will apply penalties, granularly (by page, entire website...) and real time, but if I'm penalized and disavow bad links, I will recover my initial state as if nothing happened or I will remain in shadows? what do you think?
What the hell is this ... Mostly keywords was ranked on 2nd page for development and mobile keywords now all gone to 100+.. very disappointed by this update... don't know what to do... some times ranking shows improved but from last 4 days it's gone...gone and gone :(
Haven't realized any sort of major impact in the search rankings yet for one of my clients who is still to be reconsidered. Wondering what's wrong.
As we all know the Penguin is a kind of filter designed to catch the sites that are spamming Google’s search results or violating the Google's Policy, in ways that Google’s regular spamming systems might not detect. So for that reason Penguin update is important.
Since this latest update it has affected local organic SEO for local companies. Why? Well if you were to search for a "Water Well Driller Near Me" Almost if not all the organic results are NON local water well businesses. Personally this is a huge error on behalf of Google unless of course they are trying to force more small business into AdWords or a larger AdWords spend. It is frustrating me to no end.
I work on dozens of sites and I have not seen almost any difference. I can see basically the same "dance" as any other week, but not any special change on my sites. I think that if you make white hat link building, you should not be worried about this update.
Hi Dr. Peter J. Meyers
In my opinion Google also said that with this update, will not confirm penguin future updates, so this time we will realize officially, actually means, we will have to understand the changes; and not expect Google to keep updating future updates based on Penguine SERPs.
As well as we expected a reordering of SERP because in the next few days will be taking the new order
My site rankings have been ok since the algorithm change, but I've been on the lookout. Thanks.
I have seen some of the site dropping in the rankings but I agree that the rollover would not happen overnight and will take time to show it's effect. We however should be ready to fix whatever issues Google may see with our websites.
Aha penguin stuck again? Well at least the issue of the bonds will be regulated and should be better links refine our strategies. Nothing touches companions again redefine off page strategies.
Thank for the updates. My blog is doing better after recently update. Even getting better and better. The only reason behind this possitive improvement is rapidly watch and controll upon backlinks. All my backlinks are natural format and with high DA and PA blogs, news sites.
My recommendation is to keep watching mozcast and manage your desicions accordingly.
I've started to see site improvements for keywords that were penalized ( I.E. didn't rank better than page 3 or page 5 for some words, no matter what good content was added, links were disavowed, backlinks that were good built or internal linking adjusted ). Now these words are all page 2 or better and still signs show that's not done. Not to mention I haven't seen competitors with KNOWN bad links leave the 1st page, so I think that part of this algo is yet to take place until all those links connected are crawled and devalued.
Hi Peter
The truth is that right now I just realize that Google indexing in many of my pages has changed for the better !!!
Hi, After 6 months have your positions got worse again?
Some good solid facts here Dr Pete, about the updates and in particular the Possum update and how it is separate from the Penguin update.
Hello Dr. Peter,
Well this month has been very volatile for me, the starting of September was awesome, my website's keywords jumped to great position, all of the sites in fact saw a huge boost but then suddenly all of them dropped badly, let's see what this update gives, expecting to see things getting better within days.
It may be a co-incidence, few days back I was reading a post on an SEO website (may be search engine roundtable) about Penguin, in the comments on that post an unknown person commented "Date for penguin 23-09-2016", the update happened on same date.
Keeping an eye on positions and keywords behavior.
Thanks
Hello Dr.Peter
Great post! Some of my traffic took a nosedive my website doctor told me I over-optimized my anchor text. so yes it has been a volatile month for SERP. Again thanks for sharing this value-packed post that put so many of us in the loop.
Great article. I need your expert opinion on a problem I am facing with my website. Someone is spamming my website cracku with back links some of them are nofollow and some of them are dofollow, as we provide education material for students many blogs and websites are placing some of our pages as site wide links in their menu. Due to which our spam score has increased. I have uploaded a disavow file in search console. My question is how long will google take to uncosider these links? Or is there any other way to disavow these links?
[link removed by editor]
Atleast some Whitehats will be visible in top 10 , by the way when is the update gonna be effective???
Given it doesn't exist, Never
My site sudden loose traffic, As a newbie, i become tensed , you are right, this is volatile month for SERP, My keywords are moving, one day they are around 20, next day they are out of 30. huh
Thanks Peter for sharing this
Google Penguin updates: Google says it now runs in real time within the core search algorithm. Penguin 4.0, will also be the last, because of it new real-time nature & also it is now part of core algorithm....Now collecting a good natural link may be give you boost of ranking or if just look unnatural means you will be penalize by Google Core Rankings...... :) Thank A Lot Peter for the Updates ..
Hi,
First of all i would like to thank you Mr. Peter to share this post with us.
This is great news I guess that means I should resume blogging and not worrying so much about updating posts.
Could this 'granular' mean Penguin is now targeting at a keyword level ?
Maybe they're just targeting non brand, for high spend PPC. I can't see any update, more of a filter really to isolate PPC potential revenue.
Thanks Good info
in real time means that we are all going to have changes each day in the serps?
From a Penguin perspective, we assume "real time" means that new link data is accounted for by the algorithm as soon as it's available. Crawling and storing those links takes time, though, especially across the deep web, so there will still be time lags.
In a general sense, though, SERPs already change every day. Some change every few minutes (especially for high-volume news queries). SERPs are very much a real-time thing. Some are fairly stable, just because content is fairly stable or they're dominated by high-authority sites, but some change almost every time you check them.
hi,
In my website from the 19th of September, has de-indexing AMP me a page of my site, not if it has something to do this Penguin update 4.0.
Regards
The last two days have seen strange variations as much as 100% for my sites.
yeah now its real-time as the news announced i check all my blogs and ask some of my friend also but not seen major sudden in serp . may be update rolling out slowly by and by the end of month we can see changes,
thanks for sharing
I think this update occurred long before our friends at Google announced it.
The results aren't that indifferent to where they were, but I have noticed some sites listing in serps that definitely shouldn't be there (and these only started to list early this month).
Thanks for sharing. Very interesting observation about serps with images.
We're like scientists here discovering an evidence that aliens truly exist. It's like passing by regular people down the street as they continue with their normal lives while we run back and forth in our minds because we know something big is going to happen, something huge will definitely impact our lives.
Send us more updates, Moz. Thank you so much!
Thanks, I've written a more comprehensive review of Google's Penguin 4 Update https://linkaudit.co.uk/blog/google-penguin-4-review/ which outlines what we are seeing at The Link Auditors. Though there are many more changes that have taken place than have been currently announced, and somewhat more interesting insights into the way in which Google have been challenged internally and why these updates have taken so long in this article.
Respectfully, I disagree with the September 2 assessment. There is solid evidence of a separate update near that date that was not Penguin related. There is decent (although not as solid) evidence of 2-3 updates in September that were not directly connected to Penguin. This is a very difficult thing to separate.
I'm convinced the update on Sept. 1st goes beyond possum.
Thanks for a great post. When I first looked deeper into the update (after 'dancing' calmed down a bit) my first thought was: It's like Apple releases numerous bands for Apple Watch and everyone waits for something serious :)
But when I looked deeper into it, it appeared to be much more complicated.
So far so good here in the UK, no major movements from what I have seen, but it could be a couple of weeks before it is fully rolled out. Hopefully, the granularity of the algorithm will mean that any effects are at page level as opposed to a blanket penalty to the whole site giving people more of a chance to recover should they be hit this time around.
Good luck all, I am sure we will all hear and see more in the coming days, weeks ahead.
Hi Tim,
Just to update you, here in UK, We have seen drops in ranking with few of our campaigns and Increase in on other campaings this morning as we started. I think we are getting the updated results as result of recent Penguin update.
Thanks for the Sharing this valuable info.
This Penguin Update seems to real-time and I have experienced the ranking differences with my website. Hope will regain the ranking positions as of earlier.
How did you work out its realtime, when Google have said it will take over a year to roll out? That's if you beleive them at all!
Yes, now we had a real time Penguin. I think, it will have a very effective impact that will courage those folks(including me) who do things as Google wants. So, sit tight and will see impact in coming days.
Thanks Dr. Peter for sharing combine data with us. I'm going to keep following you on same.