There's SEO challenges, and then there's SEO mountains. In the world of search marketing, perhaps nothing seems more initially daunting than a site/brand/product/entity with little to no search volume. It's not commonplace, but in several sectors, particularly some sites in niche hobbies, the arts, nonprofits and startups, there can be times when what you're producing isn't something people are asking the search engines about (yet).
My idea to build and market metal whiteboards using SEO could be challenging...
If and when that's the case, there are other ways to get organic traffic - content marketing, blogging, social media, email, public relations, etc. - but there's also several SEO techniques that can be cleverly applied.
The Substitute, i.e. It's the New "Fill-in-the-Blank"
Many products, brands or websites may not have direct search volume, but they can be thought of and marketed as similar to an existing solution/brand. When that's the case, targeting keywords that fit the bill for that substitute can present an effective proxy stream of (potentially) relevant search traffic.
For our example above, we might create content like:
- Whiteboards are SO 20th Century: Evolve to Metal
- Glass Whiteboards: Transparent? Or Too Transparent?
- Whiteboard Paint is NOT the Answer; Metal Is.
These blog posts, articles or sales pages could then rank alongside the product that ours is seeking to replace, and though they may not be a 1:1 match, the substitution could attract awareness and attention of the new player in the marketplace.
The Comparison
Many products and brands won't have properties to truly substitute for an existing search query. But, in most cases, they will be comparable to something familiar and queried.
Imagine, for example, a new form of artistic body-modification that renders portions of one's skin transparent for 5-6 days. It's not really a tattoo or body painting, but more an artistic way to illustrate one's sub-dermal anatomy. Let's call it "transparantizing"
In this peculiar case, we might not be able to honestly call it a substitute for a tattoo (or exploratory surgery for that matter), but we could create content to compare them, such as:
- Tattoos, Henna, Body Paint & Transparantizing
- Comparing Exploratory Surgery, MRIs, X-Rays and Transparantizing
This technique can be applied to real-world situations, too. A local Seattle startup, Gist.com, provides a plug-in for Gmail and Outlook to show social information about an email contact (highly useful for salespeople, in particular). Although they're not a substitute for something like Salesforce or contact management software, they can certainly compare their offerings to these popular (and high demand) queries.
Attract the Audience, Not the Query
For some brands, organizations and sites, comparables may be challenging or simply not enough. When it seems as though all direct paths to relevant traffic are stymied, remember the goal of demographic advertising. Rather than directly marketing to an audience that's expressed a clear interest, demographic ads seek to reach an audience target defined by their age, gender, income and other personal traits. SEO can accomplish a similar task, but it requires some careful planning and preparation.
First, you'll need to know as much about your target audience as possible. In our transparantizing example, let's imagine one target group is doctors and surgeons. What types of sites do they visit? What demographic and psychographic attributes apply to them? And, most importantly, what kinds of queries do they perform on a regular basis?
If we knew that our targets were regularly querying for information about medical devices, techniques, journal articles, etc. we could create a blog with content focused on those topics, discussing precisely those types of content matters. Alongside the blog's primary content on these relevant topics, we could show off the brand/product to a group of highly relevant, potentially interested clients.
Articulate's E-Learning Blog
A great real-world example comes from Articulate, which creates e-learning software. Their blog features posts like 100 Powerpoint Tutorials & Free Templates, A Boatload of Free Hand-Drawn Graphics, and How to Create Color Schemes in Powerpoint to Match Your Brand. Many of us naturally do this with our content marketing - creating related "content" that appeals to our potential audience of buyers. It's a great way to combine the power of SEO with the awareness of audience-targeted marketing.
Build the Brand
Last, but not least, the tactic of brand building has been around for decades as a method to increase awareness of a new product. When Pepsi or Coke launch a new beverage, they rarely turn to search, but they do bombard the airwaves and the web with advertising, promotions, contests and sponsorship to help create demand in the minds of consumers. Brand building is typically less-targeted than audience-marketing, but again, search can help.
Wow... Ricky Gervais did a video for Transparentizing! That's going to get a lot of views.
Those same contests, celebrities, adverts and viral videos can be made with SEO-savvy to help visitors searching for related content get exposure to your brand/product.
SEO is certainly not the answer to all marketing quandries, but neither is it completely useless in cases like these, where keyword search volumes may not be exciting, but secondary applications of search rankings can still attract great customers.
One of the things I've always loved about SEO and organic marketing, more broadly, is the power of creativity and imagination to have an impact. Don't let road bumps like "0 search volume" stand in your way; think outside "broad match" and opportunities will present themselves.
p.s. If anyone invents metal whiteboards or a technique to temporarily turn skin invisible, all I ask is proper link attribution :-)
Soo, am I the only one who actually ran off to see if Ricky Gervais indeed did a funny video about transparantizing? Heh... I mean... uh... how's the weather today?
Anyway, great timing on this article, Rand. I just finished doing some work very similar to this for a client.
He operates a rather sizable independent auto repair garage, and was looking to market his company as a specialist for a certain make of vehicle. Well a mechanic of course is looking to target local business, and my research was showing that there weren't many people directly searching for a "InsertVehicleMake" specialist in the local market.
My solution? Come out with some interesting and informative content from a professional's (the mechanic in question) point of view about various topics regarding the vehicle type. One was about how this certain type of car has recently grown much more reliable under new ownership, and thus is now a better value to own if you're looking for a new car.
Another article is about how the manufacturer recently developed an awesome new technology for their cars which provided an immediate benefit to the owner... and their mechanic! (see the tie-in there?).
Keep in mind that many times local newspapers, who usually have strong websites, are looking for good Op-Ed pieces to publish for their reader base (a form of guest blogging). It's all about widening your view and finding the opportunities.
Hah hah Frank! Thanks for making me feel better about my gaffe with the phantom Ricky video.
Rand - I have discovered this problem while working with Veterinarians.
Typically the type of person searching for a vet are looking for one within 5-10 miles of their home location. Iam dominating the SERPS with keyword strings such as; Vet City Name State etc, but they weren't searched enough, high but not high enough. So i dug deeper and put resources like Spay, and Neuter, and Equipment, and Speciality Practice and have found a much higher conversion rate.
I am grateful to hear that this is a common problem for SEO's because all of the keyword research tools in the world can't give you an exact search volume for small cities so it's a guessing game with Insights as to if this is a convertible KW or not. Or if it's actually searched highly or not.
Edit: Also with the change that Google made to places, it's made it easier to see results from General keywords, because you don't have to rely on the full string. For example someone in the area searching for Veterinarian alone, by its self, will find the map listing with mine being at the top.
Thanks as always,
argh, i nearly searched metal whiteboards just to have a look!
damn you and your crafty ways, rand!
LOL Ian. I'm guilty of searching for "Ricky Gervais turns skin Transparentized" Only after a separate sub-search did I realize I'd been had. [feeling like a dope]
Ok, have to say this even before I've finished to read the post: that first image is a very common one for me (us?) working on .it/.es markets and having to deal with niche markets.
Ok read... to think out of the box is the only possible solution, as doing the good damn SEO job is not enough. I mean, if it is already hard to emerge in a mature market, everybody who's have to deal with startups (to name one case) knows how difficult can be to make the "web" light spot move over you.
Personally I use mostly the blog tactics you cited (combined with Social), well planned after a deep market research. It is something I've learnt when doing the television programming of a thematic channel about series. If we wanted to compete against Fox and similar big budget channels, what we need to know better then ourselves was our potential audience and then go straight against the established channels without fear and searching a (civic) confrontation: David against Goliath. None was rerunning old scifi tv classics (let say "Space 1999", "U.F.O."...) we know people was eager to see again, as we discovered also thanks to deep web surfing into blog/fansites/tv forums? So let propose them again on Prime Time. People was complaining that Series were abandoned? Let's buy them and show them one season after the other without seasonal breaks (we did it with Seinfeld, Frasier). We knew our public was looking for not-ordinary-things, so we scouted for not-ordinary-series knowing that our public was the precursor of a general need: The Office (Ricky Gervais one), South Park, Dr.Who, Sex and the City, Nip/Tuck...
So, returning to websites, yes it possible to conquer search traffic even though the statistics show you the infamous "not enough data": you have to know your public very much more than just in relation to your product. Only doing this you can create demand and, especially, that connection that makes that a searcher become a client and become a fan/evangelist of your brand: also if it is a metal whiteboard.
As I read once:
"Everybody pulls for David, nobody roots for Goliath" (Wilt Chamberlain)
I'm amazed at the histories behind many in the field. It's quite an eclectic mix.
Your background in Italian film/tv is a fascinating backdrop to your SEO efforts G. It's interesting how you can pull from that ezperience to bolster your SEO. I sense a good YOUmoz comparing film/tv with SEO. [/hint]
This post is why I'm a Randfish fan. Love it love it love it.
This is a problem I first encountered on the PPC side of things, where this seems to be a more common problem (it's easier to be proactive about going after long tail products/keywords where there is little or no volume, and more evident when you are digging in the wrong areas.)Â This post is full of great suggestions that really work, so don't get discouraged when you run up against this kind of a situation.
The only thing I would add is to keep in mind that just because you can't see the volume doesn't mean it isn't there. At the end of the long tail of demand, it's hard to accurately measure search volume without actually testing things. Without going on a rant about the Google keyword tool, I'll just say that I never trust its volume estimates, especially when I work my way out towards the long tail. So, at the end of the day, testing is hugely important (but when is it not? :)
Agreed - keyword volume estimates are extremely unreliable in the long-tail. I've heard a lot of people say things like "I can't rank for 'widgets' but there's no traffic for 'blue polka-dotted titanium widgets'," and then they just give up. There's a whole lot in between, a whole lot of long-tail to sum up, and a lot of related keywords and audience keywords, as Rand suggests. Sometimes, you have to work for it a bit.
"...the power of creativity and imagination to have an impact...think outside broad match and opportunities will present themselves." We're really talking about marketing here, not just SEO and that's great! I think 'the purple cow' and SEO have a great future together.
You are forgetting the Tribus ;)
Perhaps there is an idea for a new marketing post: Purple Cow vs Golden Calf https://bit.ly/7MHAFO
:)Â
Transparantizing eh? Someone's clearly just started watching Fringe.
I was intrigued by the title and unlike on some other article sites (cough), the content didn't disappoint. Working in web hosting, which is obviously so competitive, we tend to forget the disadvantages of extreme niches with very low search volumes - but in a lot of cases, our customers are the ones trying them out. One to bookmark, and pass on when we're asked about it, so many thanks. - Jenni
I'm simultaneously frustrated and pleased by this blog post. Frustrated because I was preparing my own post on this exact subject and now I'm going to risk looking like a plagiarist. Pleased because the points you are making are the same as mine and it feels good to see my own ideas validated by none other than The Great Rand ;).
We have helped a couple of clients recently with this issue recently. The first problem is indeed capturing traffic from search when no one realises the product even exists. The second comes when you have to instantly communicate you haven't misled them and you have a relevant alternative solution to their need. It's not an area of search you see much written about which was why I'm still going to post on it. I'll make sure to add some new points not mentioned in the above.
Paul North
You should totally still finish the YOUmoz and submit it Paul. I'd bet that it's coming from a different slant and as far as I'm concerned, I can't get enough of the subject.
Branding is one thing we should not ignore in the seo industry as well, when there are no search results for the keyphrase then optimizing your website for your brand name becomes more important & useful in long run as company are always advertising their brandname in different media & if company is not optimized for its brand name then it becomes diffcult for them to be found online.
I have used such statergy before & got really good results for a client in past. Many times it happens that you get to optimize the website for a niche where there are no searches & pulling traffic becomes really hard, but you always have an alternate way to get things done right.
Great post, and something that is very relevant to my business. Not to totally side-track the topic, but does anyone have any advice on how to tackle this same issue with PPC? in my Adwords account, not enough searches results in none of my ads being shown... counter-productive methinks! thanks!
Excellent article and great advice. The funny thing is, I have actually been working on a whiteboard product and intend to launch it soon. Its basically a desktop whiteboard that can stand on its own, like a picture frame. Its the size of an A4 paper and gives you the opportunity to jot down your daily to-do's without having to waste paper in the form of post-its. Furthermore, some variations also include a clock and calender along with the whiteboard facility. I was hesitent to share this idea here but it was too tempting because you mentioned innovation in whiteboards in your article!
Passed this post over to a friend with a new product, if he reads it, he'll learn a lot.
BTW Rand, we do wall wraps in dry erase :-)
Great article,thanks!
I think for start ups with little to now budget hiring a market research agency to find out the audience,doing substitute KWs and comparison is the best choice.
We have pretty much KW tool out there to find out the best KW niche to target on.And those tools often cost little.
As an SEO,we always have to remember what Rand said in the article,SEO is certainly not the answer to all marketing quandries, but neither is it completely useless in cases like these...
Great post Rand, but don't you think that spammers have done this in the past? I don't think I've seen too much of it lately, but I'm sure in the mid 00's we were getting serps where keywords to generate traffic were used instead of real keywords and the website was actually nothing to do with the keywords you searched on?
If used correctly then it's a great idea and one I will be looking into :0)
Thanks for the tips. Nothing is impossible. Although it may take time in the initial phase. But once flow started it will be more and more chances of getting high rank with the target keyword.
Very creative and easy to understand. As I was reading it I kept wondering how long it took you to come up with the titles for the articles - I see the trick of it, though.
If only that were my problem - I am in the 'other' game - where the word (ecards) is very competitive and it is a struggle to get attention.
Any pointers?
Thanks for this post, I’ve been asking around for advice on just this subject for quite some time with no real answers, till now. You are a SEO hero!
This is all too common for the type of client I deal with unfortunatly. :( I deal a hell of a lot with small businesses who promote thier products and services within a small area, so I generally have to rely on Local SEO. Which cuts down the volume of searchs dramatically. Search terms such as "Tyre Fitters Birmingham" "Florists Nottingham" etc.. dont tend to show up as recording search volume in both the Google Adwords tool or Webmaster Tools (After the site is launched).
In some cases SEO has proved more or less a poison chalice with the amount of time spent trying to make it effective. Search Volumes are just not there, yet I have achived rankings for the chosen terms. Luckily Google PPC is a different kettle of fish with the localised targgeting options and "Broad" keyword matches.
Awesome post... Thanks.
I spent almost as much time trying to figure out how metal writing boards would work as I did reading the post. (I stopped at that paragraph, not realizing that the Rand was using humor to illustrate a point). Nice one.
Great post Rand! I liked it. As we all know that building brand is not a easy task. It takes lot of time & efforts.The building brands is the most creative & innovative process which requires a lot of thoughts. Every company whether it is small or large it requires branding the company name, products & services.
I faced that problem when dealing with a small start-up that was answering a need nobody searched for.
I tried to explain to them that SEO was not the solution but they had a hard time grasping that idea and kept giving me generic keywords that they were sure "would drive a lot of trafic".
very nice post Rand. I often find myself in situations like this especially when consulting B2B engineering firms. You wouldn’t believe some of the niches these people can come up with. Ill pass this post around the office. Thanks again
Thanks for the good ideas!
Some brilliant ideas for sites that have no search demand, in niche markets it can be important to think outside the 'broad match'.
This post was a total home run for me Rand. I'm faced with having to be creative more often than not, and I find sometimes the well of creativity runs kinda dry. Thanks for sharing the out-of-the-box tips and for inspiring me to be more creative.
Absolutely fantastic timing, I am just starting a new project and it's a variation of a whiteboard and about to go to market, but no, it's not metal!! Thanks for the tips, will certainly help with the challenge I have ahead! :-)
I have been very frustrated trying to find SEO Keywords for my blog. My niche doesn't even exist--at least I can't find it. My site, https://ClimbingEveryMountain.com is for parents of adults with autism and severe disabilities.Â
I've found many sites of parents of young children with disabilities, sites for self-advocates or people with autism or other disabilities, but I haven't been able to locate any keywords or blogs for parents of adults with disabilities. When I do a Google search, I usually come up with university research studies.
1. I'm thinking part of it has to do with the tech generational factors--many parents (I'm in my 60's) didn't grow up on computers or finding information on the web.
2. Another factor might be that there is so little research dollars and no federal mandates to serve adults. So there are not the typical resource sites that are available for children. No money, no profits.
3. Maybe parents of adults are just too exhausted from the day to day care and don't have any energy left to read blogs.
So, I just throw in a bunch of topical meta words and hope something connects for the SEO All in One. I get very few referrals from Google.
I've been concentrating on content, but when I spend so much time on each post, it is discouraging when there are few readers.
I can't even find sites to link to.
Any suggestions greatly appreciated. Thanks. Mary
I think it also creates a branding opportunity too. If you have a large enough marketing budget you could build content around a specific term you want people to use when referring to your product. As it grows in notoriety you enjoy the benefit of being the dominant destination for search traffic.
Creativity always counts. Whether it's SEO, Social Media, or just running a business. Good stuff, Rand.
 Great ideas for some creative content creation in order to get the word out. Always appreciate creativity for these sort of problems.
Easier said than done Rand. I have worked in the whiteboards industry. Though there is a search volume but people convert more through social media and offline branding. I don't think a seo can develop market for a product. If there is no demand for a product then there will be little to no search volume. If you want to develop online demand you turn to social media and display advertising and not seo. Many may argue that social media is a part of seo. Yes it is. But it is certainly not a subset of seo nor any other internet marketing channel. SEO can be of no use for several industries like steel, cement, industrial machinery, chemicals, fertilizers, Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) like soft drinks, soaps, toothpaste etc. I can confidently say that no amount of seo will ever make your soft drink next pepsi or coke. There are certain industries/markets where seo won't work. So i would not waste my time trying to do seo for such sites and products.
seo-himanshu: "I don't think a seo can develop market for a product."
I have to disagree there. If you have a brand new product, SEO can clearly be used to let people know about it as Rand has demonstrated above. After that, it is down to the product to convince people. Sometimes a new concept can be so compelling that customers will take a punt and purchase. I have seen SEO do this many times.
I agree with the role of social media etc but an integrated approach makes sense for any product, really.
I also agree that I wouldn't use SEO to sell a soft drink.
SEO can capitalize on the existing demand but can't create a demand for a product. This is what i meant. For e.g. if you sell products like Inflatable Wife, beer burglar alarm, subtle butt, earth dog tag (all real life examples) etc. you can't create demands for these product through SEO or can you?
Well, maybe the Inflatable Wife ... *cough*
I would begin by identifying keywords that are used by the target market. For Subtle Butt they would be things like "odour neutralisers" or "flatulence problems". For the Space Dog tags I think you've got to work with "gift" keywords, and drill into the long tail with keywords such as "gifts for UFO fans" etc until you run out of search volume. You optimise the site, produce the required content, link bait etc. The traffic arrives on the site then buys the products and/or tells their friends etc. Thus, building awareness. Let the amount of work you do per product be dictated by how many keywords you can think of and their combined traffic.
You are going to develop a new nickname Himanshu. The Devil's Advocate :) I have to disagree with you as well H. Some of Rand's ideas in the post were an excellent use of SEO. Specifically "The Comparison" What a brilliant way to tag your brand new brand and attach it to existing brands that are well established and searched for.
You had said If you want to develop online demand you turn to social media and display advertising  and I do agree with that, but adding SEO is a prudent step IMHO.
Looking for web marketing aid and web marketing business development consultency. web marketing business needs to consultant and web marketing business with the flexible services. Need to complete solution and gurantee we will add value to web marketing business while the current return.
What the what?
Clearly through this effort you're going to rank at the top of the SERPS for both Webmarketing Business, as well as Webmarkeing consultency (sic).
Bravo!
Ranking number 1 shouldn't be hard, since I just checked and there's no traffic showing in Google -- even if consultancy is spelled correctly. Â Einstein SEO, Inc. Â Having TOO much fun reading the comments today!
Spam comment in an SEO blog.. hilarious.Â
I think saim420 has been hitting the 420 a little too hard!
ROTFL! Please keep this spam up just for the entertainment value Jen. The very best part of it is that not only does he leave no link, he leaves no way to contact him or find his company.