The self-congratulatory titled thread at Cre8asite - When cre8asiteforums rhymes with generosity... - is producing some interesting material. Many folks, myself included, note that they use Cre8asite as a place to send potential clients who have more time than budget to take on their SEO or webdev project.

On the reverse of that argument, phaitful notes:

I'd say most clients aren't interested in spending the amount of time and effort searching the forums to find the "free" information. Many clients simply would rather pay a set fee.

Just like any other consulting service or outsourcing, you can probably do most of the tasks in house... but do the costs and time justify doing it in house or is it simply easier and faster to outsource it.

Ammon Johns chimes in with similiar experience:

In addition, a number of SEO companies over the years have employed me as a consultant. One of the first to do so explained the reason perfectly: "We could devote 30+ man-hours each week to keeping up with all the stuff you do, or we can hire you for one hour to chat with us and get the same info."

So long as it is cheaper to talk to me for an hour or two than to employ a reasonably skilled researcher to trawl through forums, papers, studies, and run their own studies and test sites just to get the same qualified answers, I'm guaranteed to be the smart businessman's choice.

The SEO forums, including Cre8asite, are where a majority of my initial knowledge and ablity to do SEO work comes from - those 30+ hours a week spent reading blogs, forums, news articles, etc. certainly do describe my surfing habits and probably the reason so many folks are anxious to get a few consulting hours. It's just interesting to have it put into words.