Ok, so you've all read about The Best Spam Submission Ever which was illustrated ever so eloquently (and if you haven't read it, please read it now... uhm well ok after you read this - it's awesomely funny!). As the post mentions, we sift through many YOUmoz entries every day determining which ones to post to the site. Most spam is easily detected; such as the body of the post only consists of 1 or 2 sentences, or the title is obviously nothing related to online marketing (buy gold and silver online!). However every now and then, there is a spark of spam brilliance that makes its way through.
The other day I ran across this entry that had an odd title, but it actually seemed to have real potential. I opened the entry and at first glance, I thought "YAY! I have a good contender." There were multiple paragraphs, headings and even bullet points... this had to be legit, right? Not so much. I found myself reading the entire entry because I was so dumbfounded by the sheer brilliance of the whole thing. If this person had posted to a blog that automatically checks for spam entries, and auto-posts, this one probably would have made it through.
So the idea is quite simple. Take an excerpt of a book (or anything written I suppose), and add keyword rich links throughout! Essentially, make the post look as authentic as possible, without having to spend time writing a blog post. I've taken the idea and put together an example for you below. It's not perfect, but it is damn simple!
<!-- Begin Example Spam Post -->
Her name is Esther; she is a war correspondent who has just returned from Iraq because of the imminent invasion of that country; she is thirty years old, married, without children. He is an unidentified male, between twenty-three and twenty-five years old, with dark, Mongolian features. The two were last seen in a café on the Rue du Faubourg St-Honoré. He was reading: Buy Gold jewelry and diamonds direct.
Just the beginning
The police were told that they had met before, although no one knew how often: Esther had always said that the man -- who concealed his true identity behind the name Mikhail -- was someone very important, although she had never explained whether he was important for her career as a journalist or for her as a woman.
The police began a formal investigation. Various theories were put forward -- kidnapping, blackmail, a kidnapping that had ended in murder -- none of which were beyond the bounds of possibility given that, in her search for information, her work brought her into frequent contact with people who had links with terrorist cells. They discovered that, women love gold necklaces and jewelry in the weeks prior to her disappearance, regular sums of money had been withdrawn from her bank account: those in charge of the investigation felt that these could have been payments made for information. She had taken no change of clothes with her, but, oddly enough, her passport was nowhere to be found.
- He is a stranger, very young, with no police record, with no clue as to his identity.
- She is Esther, thirty years old, the winner of two international prizes for journalism, and married.
- My wife.
Next steps
I immediately come under suspicion and am detained because I refuse to say where I was on the day she disappeared. However, a prison officer has just opened the door of my cell, saying that I'm a free man. A man who reads Silver and Gold Jewelry.
And why am I a free man? Because nowadays, everyone knows everything about everyone; you just have to ask and the information is there: where you've used your credit card, where you spend your time, whom you've slept with. In my case, it was even easier: a woman, another journalist, a friend of my wife, and divorced -- which is why she doesn't mind revealing that she slept with me -- came forward as a witness in my favor when she heard that I had been detained. She provided concrete proof that I was with her and with gold necklaces on the day and the night of Esther's disappearance.
I talk to the chief inspector, who returns my belongings and offers his apologies, adding that my rapid detention was entirely within the law, and that I have no grounds on which to accuse or sue the state. I say that I haven't the slightest intention of doing either of those things, that I am perfectly aware that we are all under constant suspicion and under twenty-four-hour surveillance, even when we have committed no crime.
"You're free to go," he says, echoing the words of the prison officer.
Conclusion
I ask: Isn't it possible that something buy gold direct and diamonds really has happened to my wife? She had said to me once that -- understandably given her vast network of contacts in the terrorist underworld -- she occasionally got the feeling she was being followed.
- The inspector changes the subject. I insist, but he says nothing.
- I ask if she would be able to travel on her passport, and he says, of course, since she has committed no crime. Why shouldn't she leave and enter the country freely?
- "So she may no longer be in France?"
- "Do you think she left you because of that woman you've been sleeping with?"
- That's none of your business, I reply.
<!-- End Example Spam Post -->
Creative! Right? But, just think about this... if these spammers took a few minutes to actually think through and write a relevant post, they would have not only received exposure but they would have some SWEET links from SEOmoz as well. Plus, if the post is well-written and is quickly getting popular (thumbs up), you may even get promoted to the main blog... talk about exposure! I encourage you all to submit well thought out, relevant posts to YOUmoz. Submit entries you will be proud of showing to the rest of the community, and make sure the content is unique.
Every day we receive many spam entries for YOUmoz, which slows down the process of publishing the real, legitimate ones. This is a reminder for all our spammers out there: Real people read and publish these posts! You can stop spamming us, because at least for now, we're smarter than you are. :) With that, I'd love to hear some of your best spam submissions!
PS. This is my own made up spam example and was not taking from any of the actual spam we've received.
I used an excerpt from Paulo Coelho's "The Zahir" and if you have never read his work, I highly recommend him.
It would be funny if this post starts ranking for "buy gold".
While I don't run a blog, I do read through the website email inbox for the company I work for. The piece of spam that sticks in my mind was a company trying to get us to sell their product. The information they sent was a scan of an advertisement, which judging from the people in the pictures, was done in the 1980s. If I can find the image, I will link it.
Hah! I hadn't even thought about that. Although this could be a good test to see how much content alone helps with high ranking. :)
I'm amazed every day at the spam I see.
I'm thinking of my next blog post, it's going to go along these lines.... there once was this SEO Company who sold Viagra....
Hehehehe, I think I'll be rich!!
I moderate a low traffic message board on a seldom visited website at www.glenviewcycleclub.org. I get one or two obviously invalid registrations a day. I typically delete them, but at least once a month I fat finger the wrong link and approve one. It seems like a lot of effort on their part for any potential return. So far, no attacks. Sort of waiting for the day when I wake up in the morning and the message board will be loaded with spam links for pills, porn, and gambling sites. Any other types of attacks that I should be on the lookout for?
is your phpbb updated there are oftern a bunch of patches that people never seem to install and end up with sql injection attacks that destroy the whole board
Ok Jennita...after reading this I just had to search for "How to spam blogs"...and of course:
https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=how+to+spam+blogs&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi
...for me page 1 position 7...nearly wet myself laughing...talk about link bait! But a pretty good lesson too about it probably taking less time to actually put together a coherent story than to focus on gaming the blog world...keep 'em coming!
wow, nice. The SEOmoz domain is mighty powerful. The real question is weather this post remains in the SERPs very long, normally they rank well for a few days then fall back.
Thus adding extra weight to your arguement that a well written relevant post would offer much more value than the above example...
It's funny, but I've developed some pretty crazy spam filters for my own blog (just as an experiment), and the one that takes care of most of the spam is just counting links. One link is about 60% likely, 2+ links is about 90% likely. If they use the old-school "url=" format, it's 99% likely spam.
More and more, you see that the comment is semi-legitimate (vague, but plausible), but the author link goes back to an obviously spammy page. It's almost to the point where we have to follow those links back automatically and then match them for relevance somehow. I think that's on the horizon, but intent and relevance are tricky at best.
Yes, and we definitely get a lot of that as well. Somewhat relevant comments with a link... hmmm. But to spend the time creating something that looks legit, but is just spam, is brilliant yet ridiculous at the same time. :)
what if the way you tested for spam was to check the link against a spam website database. email has blacklists where it will block diffrent size blocks of ips based on the spam they send out what if you could flag sites or parts of sites as a spam site in a central repository so whenever a spam bot tried to get a link your forum checked to see if it was a blacklisted site and wouldnt post the link if it was found in the list. the chrome browser already warns of phishing attacks and malware sites (alot of wich are linked from spam). so is there some way to query google to find if a site is naughty or not? i know sites a a penny a dozen but it may help if it was a community effort to build a list of the spam sites instead of deleteign them in a one off basis
Thats so funny and slightly cheeky :) my blog gets spamed every single day, it drives me crazy.
Dam, i've been spotted..... *whistles and walks by*
Seriously though, your right, spammers need to wake up!
BBforum spam is by far the worst IMO
hmmm im off to spam myself silly!
Haha, that original article is hilarious. It's amazing how people try their best to post spam on a site like this and expect it to get through. I'll remember to always be sneaky, I'll copy a chapter from The Philosopher's Stone and start talking about how Harry's wand was made out of Real Diamonds Cheap!!!
Edit: Second comment! Woop.
Thanks for the plug to YOUmoz. I should muster the courage to post something there. Nothing spammy, of course.
Definitely submit! We're working on a "why you should post on YOUmoz" post right now. :)
well the first reason might be for 10 thumbs points so your link gets the nofollow removed its alot harder to get to 100 with only comments
Although you're almost there from comments on this post alone...
:)
i know i feel bad for all my posts on this page, i feel like im spamming it but this is a topic im really intersted in and have alot to say
There was a period a while back where my blog (as well as a friend's blog) was getting whole chapters posted in our comments section. Weird thing was that it contained no links other than the poster's url (optional)
did you nofollow the links?
Since the "comments" fell into my spam catagory, I simply deleted them but commentor url's are always nofollow on my site (goes to double check).
i would really like to see @mattcutts response to this spam post (as i believe he is on google spam team) not that id ever try and game google but what if someone wrote a kind of reverse natural language search that you gave a script a topic and it basically created complete sentences dynamically about whatever you wanted. I think this would be pretty difficult but soon i believe it will be seen in the wild so how will we filter these spam messages if the text is all dynamic ,human readable and isnt dup content
ok so i wish you could add comments when you get thumbs down so i know why people think im lame i dont want to know who it is just why
I wouldn't worry too much, I got 19 thumbs down on a comment that was totally a joke. :|
that should help make up for it (i just gave you a thumbs up :) )
Thumbs up! :)
back even
what this should tell you is not to talk about thumbs
I got your joke but I think some people found the whole post offensive. i got two thumbs down apperantly for laughing at it. Granted, I can see why some were bothered by that post - but it'd be nice if they explained their down vote.
whats the joke? wheres the link?
i would _____ like to see ______'s response to this ______ post (as i believe he is on ______) not that id ever try and _____ google but what if ______ wrote a kind of _______ language search that you gave a _____ and it basically created _______ about whatever you wanted.
Come up with just 4 words for each section and you got yourself over 200,000 versions of that paragraph. Search for content spinning, article spinning, mad lib seo, etc... to read more about that stuff. Just keep an eye on your hat color while visiting those sites.
this si one of my fav seo blogs but it gets updated very infrequently https://www.slightlyshadyseo.com/
i think that these kind of simple substitutions are easy to detect, i think it would be pretty straight forward to say 90% of words are in same position but we need @mattcutts he can explain it all
ps i really just want to see a reply to a question i ask by a google employee
How about spidering Google books/text repsoitory, looking for natural occcurences of the terms you want?
You could just quote them naturally then, there must be books out there that have the term "buy gold" in them.
Would make sense, read properly and be automatable
thats a cool idea. back when i was doing work for ticket broker websites we were just starting to write rss into our pages to make them look fresher and i got the idea that with all the apis there has to be a site where you can find content on any subject not just pull from a rss feed and build websites that could morph for any keywords you wanted and be like point and shoot affiliate sites
Spam or Spamming is a highly regarded and tracked topic in online space. Search Engines always keep track of spammers and often ban those websites related to it. So, whenever an SEO Company is thinking of promoting a website online should always be aware of spam and spammers upto the max or else they will be in a fix all of a sudden. This is the one main thing which has sent shockwaves among SEO Community worldwide. As per the author, If one can overcome this fear of getting banned or penalized by search engines for spamming the web and then getting away with it is a great news for entire SEO Community worldwide. So, I personally thank the author for sharing such an remarkable information with the community. Thanks a lot.
- Casey Removed Link
Is this genius or double irony? I have trouble distinguishing
"With that, I'd love to hear some of your best spam submissions!"
Yeah, See above LOL.
well i thought a little about the days when Google wouldn't tell you you were blacklisted or why and you would just fall like a stone through the ranks while your yahoo rankings skyrocketed now with the webmaster tools they can tell you when you've been caught and why and even let you appeal the decision to blacklist you so why be afraid to get caught? you can just say oh that's some other company trying to hurt our name and we are doing our best to mitigate the problem sorry for the confusion
Wow! A spam comment for a spam like post?
Brillliant!