This format could easily turn into a series of posts if people are interested, but to start with I'm just going to look at questions relating to geo-location, internationalisation and foreign language questions. In my opinion 99% of questions on these topics can be answered by the information below. For the other 1% we'd be delighted to have you stop by Q&A and share your troubles :-)
Note: You do need to be a PRO member to read the answers to the questions I've linked to, but I've pulled out the highlights from each question for you here so that everyone can benefit from the post.
The Basics
Before I delve into the Q&A, I'm going to link to some of the best posts on the topic which we nearly always end up linking to when we're talking about geolocation and international issues:A post by Duncan on some tricky Local issues
Will is interviewed at SMX by Rand on the basics of ranking internationally
Lucy interviews local SEO experts from around the world to get their take on the usual problems
The Answer To The TLD/Sub-Domain/Sub-Folder Question
This question we see more than any other. People are ALWAYS asking which is better: www.domain.com/uk, www.domain.co.uk, uk.domain.com? The answer is "it depends," which is why we get asked the question all the time. On what does it depend, you might ask? Well, look no further, the answer is covered in these 3 Q&A:My rule of thumb with multi-location / language sites is as follows:
Things to think about when designing a global multi-lingual SEO strategy
- Any country where you will have staff in the country, language resources to write the website and / or where it will be enough of your business to justify the investment, I would target with its own cctld (e.g., a website hosted in France, written in French at domain.fr to target France)
- Anywhere that is not an option (for cost / benefit reasons - and this could be all non-English areas), I would create the country as a sub-folder on the .com and write in the local language only within that sub-folder (e.g., domain.com/pt for Portugal, in Portuguese). Test registering these sub-folders as geo-targeted within Webmaster Central. I would probably host this in the UK as you will want your English-language content to be geo-targeted to the UK. Apart from the homepage, put your English-language content in /en or /uk, depending on your preference.
Basically, my feeling is that big brands, whose content naturally earns lots of links and attention, should go for country-specific TLDs. Smaller brands, who are much less likely to earn the quantity and quality of links to each separate domain they need to rank well, should use one domain with geo-targeted sub-folders.
Subdirectories or CC TLDs?
I would probably avoid hosting a .com targeting North America in the UK as the English-language component could confuse the engines.
Geographic considerations of your web hosting provider
If you have a small business rather than a big one sometimes the answer changes; check out this question specifically for small businesses.
And to finish off this section, Jane answers a few specific questions.
International Link Building
Of course, one of the important ranking factors is links from the correct geographical location. So how do you go about link building internationally?I think using domain extension specific searches is probably an excellent way to go. For example:
- https://www.google.com/search?q=directory+site%3Aco.uk
- https://www.google.com/search?q=intitle%3Adirectory+site%3Aco.uk
- https://www.google.com/search?q=inurl%3Adirectory+site%3Aco.uk
- https://www.google.com/search?q=resources+site%3Aco.uk
You can add your specific topic/keywords (make sure you think broad) to these types of searches and find excellent places to list your site.
Geo-location/IP-based Redirection (AKA Cloaking)
While questions on this aren't as common, we see this problem giving a lot of people a hard time (probably because there are a few pitfalls to avoid!). Unfortunately, most of these questions are marked as private so I can't share them; however, the most common sources we link to when talking about this are these, so make sure you've read them before you think about any conditional redirection:Rand turns to the dark side
Does white hat cloaking exist?
The world series spidering problem
Miscellaneous Questions of Interest
This is the bracket containing those hard-to-categorise questions which are still useful and worth reading even if the problem doesn't apply to you directly:I believe the best practice for this is to use the accent in body copy and title tags (I would choose é as that should work regardless of your character encoding and your users' browser). In the URL, however, I would choose the first example www.domain.com/cinema for the user-focused reason that accents in URLs get encoded when they appear in your browser's address bar - which makes them illegible to users.
How to deal with foreign characters
Adding &gl=uk (for the UK, that is, nz for New Zealand, etc) to the end of a search query will return results as if you were in that country. For example, notice the difference between these two results on Google.com for "athletics": regular result versus Australian result.
Seeing Google as if from another country
Because you're targeting these language markets, I would go with the native spellings of the languages in your URLs, rather than the English spellings. Neither is likely to make or break the site in terms of international rankings, but this is still the route I would take.
International search language use and spelling
However, from some searching around I've seen that almost all English language queries in google.ae are returning English sites. This is mostly .com (due to the dominance of .com domains) but I've seen .co.uk sites and .com.au sites ranking as well. This suggests to me that it would be possible to rank for English language terms in google.ae with any TLD so long as the language is in English.
Geo-targeting a .me extension to the middle east
That's all, folks! Hopefully this is useful and if you're thinking of asking a question on geo-targeting or international issues, why not check out these links first!
Great roundup of questions and answers Tom. I think this post makes best practices (and practices where there is no "best") quite clear. I'd just add a couple items for those you might prefer video tutorial formats:
https://www.seomoz.org/dp/seomoz-pro-video-tips#checking-foreign-rankings
https://www.seomoz.org/dp/seomoz-pro-video-tips#international-domains
I just wish the engines were more responsive/obeyed the directions given in Webmaster Tools around geo-location. I wonder if they see abuse or if they're really inaccurate or if it's simply hard to implement.
Thanks for adding those Rand, you're right they're definitely worth checking out too.
I think the reason we get so many questions in Q&A about it is because it's so unclear what the right choice is. I'm also not sure why the geolocation indicator in webmaster central isn't weighted more heavily - it doesn't seem like the kind of thing that would be prone to high levels of spam but then those spammers are highly inventive folks...!
Hello tom,
you should change your /discuss/ urls to /view/ because they redirect to the /qa page
remi
Here's an idea in a video from Matt Cutts He confirms that the server's geographic location (IP) can affect the ranking of your site on local versions of Google. He goes on to remind us that with Webmaster tools you can chose a country for international domains such as .com and that you can do that by subdomain (the suggestion is, I suppose, that this overides the country the IP address indicates. So the Matt-Cutts solution would be to have fr.domain.com, uk.domain.com, de.domain.com etc and indicate the country for each in seperate webmastertools profils. On this video : https://www.youtube.com/GoogleWebmasterHelp#play/uploads/3/keIzr3eWK8I
Ah but it seems he copied this idea from Rand and Will !
See :
https://www.seomoz.org/blog/whiteboard-mondaysmx-west-interviews-will-critchlow-on-ranking-foreign-domains
Also, bear in mind that you can register sub-folders as well as sub-domains in webmaster central.
Yes that is mentioned in Rand and Will's video too
nice post tom, its an argument that ive had with fellow consultants about the best way to setup multiple locations.
The interesting point is that UK sites are more likely to show up on Google.com.au results is that because many Google services only offer UK or US English, and mostly that is co.uk domains not .com domains.
Hi Guys,
So it's only taken me about a month but I finally understand what you're talking about when you say the URLs don't work. It's cos those URLs are only accessible since I'm an associate!
Really sorry about that everyone - I've fixed them all now so you can go and read the Q&A (if you're pro anyway).
Thanks
Tom
I would like to see more about the best practices for a company that wants to get more international traffic/business.
I know this is an old post, but I just really appreciate. I am reseaching about our new sites, written in English and Vietnamese. Thanks for summing up some very useful posts.
I have been ask this question and I wonder if some one can answer it.
I've been ask to SEO a location in France called Barèges, does it make any difference in the SERP's if I use 'Barèges' or 'Bareges'.
Hi Chris,
Google will generally consider that Bareges and Barèges are the same word (looks like it from looking at the two SERPs) but a French person looking at the two will see one as a spelling mistake.
So in your French pages, title tags, META DESCRIPTIONS on page text I would strongly advise using the correct spelling, Barèges.
The only accepted way of writing without the accents is in uppercase BAREGES
If its Barèges in the Pyrenees, its not far from me ;-) You can see it on the tour de France this week if you have never been.
- Neil
Thanks Neil for your local knowledge and awareness of the French search habits.
70% of the users for this project would be UK holiday makers, so I am probably going to use Bereges with out the accent.
Interestingly Google Insights suggests bereges having 3 times the search volumne.
https://www.google.com/insights/search/#q=Bar%C3%A8ges%2CBareges&cmpt=q
We could satisfy all by using the uppercase BAREGES.
Thanks again Neil
I'm at the very beginning of launching my own blog and had always thought of SEO as a whole, never thought of its "international" branch as a separate entity. Your post is especially interesting for me because my blog intends to be bilingual, and its so many links make it a sort of "encyclopaedia". Thanx!
Good round-up Tom, this is the kind of questions I get asked everyday and sometimes is difficult to get the right answer across.
From what Vanessa Fox said in her blog not long time ago I believe that ccTLds carry more weight when it comes down to determine the geographical location of a site. It makes sense since it is easier to check and the country local termination is considered more trustworthy by users. As a Spaniard, if I look for product information in Spanish I would lean to chek results with a .es termination.Maybe it is something subconscious but it is the way it is and by Google knowing that it is logical to think that they might put more weight on the solutions that facilitate the user experience.
International SEO is a whole science by itself so I am glad that is starting to catch-on within the SEO community, although it is opening the pandora's box of a much more complex world.
Great post.
This is helpful and the links add much more information than the brief qutoes. I would like to see you expand this to discuss any suggestions in a Search Marketing capacity how one might add to their branding efforts in your experience of multi-lingual search engine campaigns. ie is there any validity for a site to be looking at the english language and japanese language version of google japan etc. in order to be found easier and thus gain more sales? Or is it better to just build optimized webpages for the keywords in the different languages you want to connect to?
excellent post, Tom... I find this topic fascinating albeit frustrating at times as there still doenst seem to be a clear fix for geotargeting issues on international sites. It all seems still sort of hypothetical. It would be nice to hear Matt Cutts views on this specific post. Thanks
It's all hypothetical because most of the time is "it depends", it's just different levels of hypothetical :)
This is interesting stuff. I manage a tri-lingual website (Spanish, Dutch, English) for a small international NGO. The website used to be at domain.nl only (PR4), but when I put online a new website I chose for:
Before the new domains were put to use, Google returned top results almost only for some (specific) Dutch search terms. The two new domains quickly became indexed, which already significantly improved English and Spanish search term ranking. Then after three months, both new domains jumped from PR0 to PR3.
I now feel this was the right choice, although the new website itself may have had something to do with better rankings as well. On the other hand, if I'd read by then everything on geo-targeting that I've now read, I think I would have opted for domain.org/nl, domain.org/es and domain.org/en. I'm still not entirely sure!
Great post rand. Being an Aussie these types of questions always pop up.
I didn't know about the &gl=uk thing. This is awesome. thank you for pointing that out. Will be very handy when targetting an international audience
Ive never really thought, or had to make a web site for multipal languages. The whole optimising a site for other countries and languages, seems like a big job. Not something you could just do for a couple of grand i expect. lol
This post could not come at a better time! This is my main struggle right now and my biggest challenge since involving myself with SEO.
I've put this question out there previously, but I will again to see if I get some feedback. Is it at all possible to iinclude a country select (or something similar) for the juicy link finder? This is something I struggle with in building links across three country specific sites with 99% of the same content and language, so building country appropriate links is crucial. It would make it a lot easier if the tool could just pull up juicy links from the country of your choice. What a time saver!
Thanks, Tom, for another great post ;)
Tom, very good round-up of questions and answers. I'd wonder a bit about areas like Canada which may involve French/English combinations or the USA which has typically English/Spanish mix of languages.
What are you opinions on best practices regarding catering to the language and generating the most search viability for each language pair?