A little blog humor goes a long way, and wordplay has always been a shortcut to a humorous headline.
I borrowed "A Sale Of Two Titties" from a Monty Python skit, which was a play on the title of the Charles Dickens novel, "A Tale Of Two Cities." This switching of consonants in "Tale" and "City" is known as a spoonerism, which has been around since the 19th century, having been named after a Reverend William Spooner, who apparently had a penchant for transposing letters and syllables.
A spoonerism gives Matt Cutts the farm wuzzies.
However, for this post, I would like to direct the SEOmoz readers to some more recent types of wordplay, as brought to my attention by the cunning linguists over at the delightful Language Log blog.
MONDEGREENS AND SNOWCLONES AND EGGCORNS. OH MY!
1) Mondegreens
Mondegreens are mishearings of words, typically songs or popular phrases. They were coined by writer Sylvia Wright in the 1950's when, as a child, she misheard the Scottish ballad 'The Bonny Earl of Murray':
Ye Highlands, and ye Lawlands
Oh where have you been?
They have slain the Earl of Murray,
And Lady Mondegreen. (this line should read 'And they layd him on the green')
Popular examples of Mondegreens:
When Phoebe from Friends is asked what her favorite love song is, she sings "Hold me closer, Tony Danza" instead of "Hold me closer, Tiny Dancer."
"The ants are my friends,
they're blowin' in the wind
The ants are a-blowin' in the wind."
Snowclones are a subset of cliches and are described by Erin O'Connor as "fill-in-the-blank headlines."
'"In X no one can hear you Y'
'In space no one can hear you scream'
Some other popular snowclones include:
"To X, or not to X" (Shakespeare would be proud... or not)
"That ain't an X, this is an X" (Crocodile Dundee)
"That ain't a mustache, this is a mustache"
"In Soviet Russia, X Ys you!"
Based on comedian Yakov Smirnoff's Russian Reversal jokes:
"In USA, you watch television,
In Soviet Russia, television watches you!"
Another highly popular snowclone that can be found in episodes of Family Guy, King of the Hill, Simpsons, MST3K, etc.
"What Would Jesus X"
What Would Jesus Link To?
Where to go for snowclone inspiration: The Snowclones Database
3) Eggcorns
Eggcorns are another linguistic figure coined by the Language Log guys.
As Chris Waigl wrote:
"In September 2003, Mark Liberman reported an incorrect yet particularly suggestive creation: someone had written “egg corn” instead of “acorn.” It turned out that there was no established label for this type of non-standard reshaping. Erroneous as it may be, the substitution involved more than just ignorance: an acorn is more or less shaped like an egg; and it is a seed, just like grains of corn. So if you don’t know how acorn is spelled, egg corn actually makes sense."
This lead to the identification of many more eggcorns, including some that Oxford University Press editor Ben Zimmer listed (which could almost be considered a part of mainstream English).
Which one is the eggcorn and which is the original?
A) Free Rein or Free Reign?
B) Baited Breath or Bated Breath?
C) Just Deserts or Just Desserts?
D) A Shoo-In or A Shoe-In?
What did you choose? You'd be surprised at the answers!
Where to go for Eggcorn inspiration: The Eggcorn Database
WHAT DOES WORDPLAY HAVE TO DO WITH THE INTERNET?
Mondegreens, snowclones, and eggcorns are a growing force in online writing. If you take a look at the structure of headlines at Digg or Reddit, you'll see some familiar wordplay on the front page. You'll find these linguistic occurrences are popular on satirical websites like Fark and SomethingAwful, in cartoons and TV comedies, on the radio and in movies. Custodians of grammar may frown at the decay of 'proper English', but the laziness of online writers is a boon for observing the hyper-evolution of our language. As journalist and LOLcats analyst David McRaney writes in his LOLcats expose:
"The great thing about all of this is how we can see new languages forming out of a new medium, and since the pace is abnormally fast, we can watch it evolve over weeks instead of decades."
Face it, if you're a blogger looking to appeal to the linkerati and the attention-deprived digg nation, what more could you ask for than appropriating a well known word, catchphrase, or lyric and molding it into a witty headline that combines popularity, familiar recognition, and humor?
Copywriter/editor Nancy Friedman found an error on one of mega-billionaire Warren Buffett's remarkable Berkshire Hathaway annual reports (seriously, read this PDF and tell me it's not the best annual report you've ever read) and pinged Mr Buffett, to which he promptly replied:
"Dear Nancy:
I enjoyed your letter. What we tell people is that we put one mistake in each annual report to encourage annual reading. But if you believe that ...
Sincerely,
Warren E. Buffett"
The mistake?
"Vocal Chords" instead of "Vocal Cords".
Hey, I figure if Mr Buffett's turning eggcorns into jokes, we can too.
Do you have any favorite mondegreens, spoonerisms, snowclones, or eggcorns?
Great post. Now 'scuse me, while I kiss this guy.
And never leave your pizza burinin'
Haha, the modern equivalent would probably be Fall Out Boy. This ain't a city - and he's also into cats.
I have mixed feelings about this. I don't mind when people manipulate language to be clever, but when they do it out of ignorance, it gives me the chills. Etymology shouldn't be in the hands of people who say "doggy dog world". *shiver*
I agree Lorisa. This is one big disadvantage to life on the Internet as far as I'm concerned. However, the post is still fun and well researched. :)
whats wrong with "dodgy dog world"? ;-p
it's a perfectly cromulent phrase.
Ah, I love any and all cromulent references.
My favourite mondegreen? One that will be common to most Brits who went to a C of E school I would imagine:
The Lord's Prayer
Our Father, Who Art In Heaven
Harold Be Thy Name...
I do hope that no-one of faith is offended by this; it really was a common misconception amongst English school-childer, certainly when I was young...
I do remember that one...
Hilarious AND useful...some great ways to write click-worthy (and link-worthy) headlines.
I think it's "Oxford" not "Oxfore", but they are pulling the cart of ye olde English language, so I could be wrong.
"Dear Chuck,
I enjoyed your comment. What we tell people is that we put one mistake in each blog to encourage blog reading. But if you believe that ..."
Is what I'd like to say but I'm sure there's more than one mistake! Well spotted.
Minus whale, for all in tents and porpoises, everyone makes mcsteaks.
That reminds of one I've seen kind of a lot: "for all intensive purposes." I think quite a few people believe that's correct.
A bit late to the party, but I fixed it. :)
Running OT here but what gives with the thumbs down? Who doesn't like titties? Or the rest of this post for that matter?
Great work even if the title is a bit exploitative (or did I just make that word up?). Any MP refrerence is a winner in my book.
All your thumbs down are belong to shor :(
The greatst source of egg corns are closed captions. Sometimes I think ONLY the semi-literate are allowed to do captions.
I am from Germany as well. So is my mother in law...her favorite saying includes: "The apple doesn't fall far from the pear tree" and "We'll cross that bridge when it gets here".... Only topped by me when I announced at a dinner party that I had lost my keys, couldn't find and I had looked in every crook and nanny"...or when I had my first meeting with a client over dinner many years ago and summarized the meeting by saying "good, I am glad we are all on the same plate."
So glad I can entertain those around me... lol
Lucas, I'm sorry I didn't mention this in my first comment, but I am really enjoying your posts. So far, they all seem to be about emerging trends and how we can use them in our SEO efforts. Very forward thinking. I like! Keep it up!
Thanks Lorisa, I'm having a whale of a time blogging about marketing tactics and strategies that are a little off the beaten track.
I do enjoy a good mondegreen - in fact, i wrote a post about this very topic on my music blog a while back. I'd be inclined to agree with lorisa's view on eggcorns though - i think they're probably just caused by people echoing a phrase that they've never seen written down. does this mean that eventually everything will be spelled phonetically?
another raft of daft phrases turn up when you start translating stuff too - apparently the song title 'can't buy me love' was translated in Russian as 'throw a crowbar to the old woman'....and the legendary 'bite the wax tadpole' of coca-cola...
As newcomers to America (from Germany) my big brothers came home from school and proudly recited the Pledge of Allegiance to my parents. They were adamant that it was "I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and two three fablick...".
Good work shor. Can't believe you had to rewrite much of that post - what a pain!
I am generally quite picky about grammar and spelling and stuff, but I really appreciate things like lolcats which spectacularly abuse the English language but can be very clever and subtle at the same time.
A favorite snowclone (and one I have on the board next to my desk, actually), from LOLcats: In ur X, Yin ur Z.
The life of snowclones is intriguing. At first, prior to being a snowclone, the phrase is obscure and strange. People don't get it. After a short time, people get it and it becomes funny. Quickly, it becomes a cliche and people dislike hearing it. Later still, the phrase is such a cliche and a regonised snowclone (im in ur X; in Soviet Russia) that it gains popularity again due to its overuse, rather than in spite of it.
One of my favourite forms of comedy is that which relies on the audience knowing what's coming next and / or recognising the joke.
Agreed. Other good examples come from online communities. My favorite has was fallout from the dotcom burst and Slashdot:
1- Have an idea.
2- ...
3- ...
4 - PROFIT!
I love that. Haven't been on /. for ages...
Combine it with popular culture and you get all kinds of funny.
I remember there being some great Simpsons ones.
Haha roadies, reminds me of the classic Mastercard ad:
1- Insert titties into title (2 seconds)
2- Research recent forms of wordplay (20 minutes)
3- Retyping blog after accidental deletion at 90% completion (2 hours)
4- MakiMaking the Digg front page - priceless.
My favorite misheard lyric? Found under the listing for one of my favorite songs - "Sympathy for the Devil" by the Rolling Stones.
The lyrics go: "I stuck around Saint Petersburg" which some guy reports he heard as "I stubbed my brow, saying 'Beatles Burn!'"
My ex (who is an almost-PhD) really believed that Jimi Hendrix was singing "'scuse me while I kiss this guy" up until he met me and I cured him of that. He seriously thought maybe Jimi was trying to out himself in a low-key fashion :)
Great food for thought. Well researched too! I have to agree, I could certainly use some more humor in much of my writing.
Thanks for posting this Amazing SEO Blog!! I got some amazing tips Regarding SEO.
Every thing was really very good.
Here https://www.seohimanshu.blogspot.com/ also i got some intresting things regarding SEO.
I loved this post, it was fantastic.. and reminded me of my late Grandpa who always used to muddle his words and swap letters about...
One of the most memorable was when he went on holiday and had to get some currency changed into 'Draculas' (Drachmas)
Mate,
top effort here, good insight and a few laughs along the way. Always good to hear your ponderings....
Looks like this article is feeling the Digg Effect itself. Nice Job!
Yeah... the "seo" bit in the URL hasn't killed us yet.
The digg comments are just what you'd expect too :)
Shor, That was an interesting read. Great post.
When i first saw the movie poster i read: "no one can hear icecream"
Shor, I have to admit you had me fooled here. After rolling my eyes at the title I was pleasantly surprised at the interesting, informative read. You researched it well. Thanks.
Never expected to see a SEOmoz blog post with titties in the title....I guess it got me to clickthough from my reader though. Effective...
I assume you haven't been reading too long.
Search:
titties
Bear Balls
SEOmoz is rife with naughty turns of phrase, try some in the search.
It's like looking for naughty words in the dictionary.
inflate,
Been reading a while...btw there's only one other mention of "titties" outside of this post and it was in a comment. Not sure that qualifies as "rife with naughty phrases". I'll let it slide though...
Ha ha! Didn't mean to tarnish your credibility. I should have given a more robust example.
Try this SEOmoz Dirty Words
Shor,
Great article! Until now I have felt the effect but not known the mechanics behind some of the greats titles on Digg or Reddit.
So much to learn so little time!!
how about the classic Iron Butterfly's in-a-gadda-da-vida?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida_%28song%29
Reminds me a little of this:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Deeper-Meaning-Liff-Douglas-Adams/
dp/0330322206/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/202-9332952-3756619?ie=
UTF8&s=books&qid=1192695502&sr=8-2
(apologies for dodgy link)
don't come out tonight.
they're bound to take your life.
there's a bathroom on the right.
As I do agree that there are many uses of these , and I have seen them all over the web like you say,
I guess if its done write and still is easy to read then its good,
Do major newspapers like the "NY Times" , (which by the way is supposed to be on a lower resding lever ) , use this kind of writing?
"As I do agree that there are many uses of these , and I have seen them all over the web like you say,"...
me too...wait, what are you referring to?
I was refering to all those sites I see with the annoying writing....:)
Certainly in the UK, headline writers (generally sub-editors) are renowned for using word-play. However, there is now a push to remove this sort of thing so that articles can be found via search.
So Shor's column ignites an interesting debate:
Write for SEO or social media?
I guess the answer would be both.
For anyone interested in writing headlines for SEO, can I (kind of humbly) point them to my own YOUmoz article on the subject?
SEO For Journalists: Headlines & Body Copy