Last week, I covered searching for potential links through highly ranking sites at the engines. Today, we'll talk about competitive link searches - finding the links your competetion is using to rank well. As an example, I'll use Farecast, a local Seattle company that I've mentioned in the past (full disclosure: David Shim, who works there, is a friend). Since Farecast will want to rank for terms like "plane ticket prices," "compare airfare," and "cheap airline tickets" they'll be competing against some of the web's largest travel properties.
The first step in any good competitive link campaign is to discover your competition. Many times, there will be a lot of sites that you didn't see as competitors initially. Remember that any site that ranks in the top 10-20 for your primary target search terms is, for these purposes, considered a target. Thus, a great way to start is by listing the 20-50 most competitive search terms & phrases that you want to rank for and searching for the top 20 listings at Yahoo!, Google & MSN. Once you've got your results, you'll want to take note of those sites that consistently rank in the top 5 for many different phrases as well as identifying other potential targets that rank 6-20 on a regular basis.
I've made a short list from just a few searches for Farecast:
- www.orbitz.com
- travel.yahoo.com
- www.cheaptickets.com
- www.cheapflights.com
- www.sidestep.com
- www.planetickets.com
- www.priceline.com
- www.travelocity.com
- etc.
From here, I'll use Sidestep.com as an initial source. The following are the major competitive link searches that I regularly use:
Direct Link Searches:
Note that MSN & Yahoo! tend to list more important links higher than less important links, so by searching through the top 1-200, you're, in general, getting the most "powerful" links the site has. There also appears to be a temporal component to link searches, so newer links will appear before older ones.
- Google - link:www.sidestep.com (practically useless)
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com (at SiteExplorer)
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com - site:sidestep.com
Keyword-Embedded Link Searches:
Google doesn't allow these and neither does Yahoo! Site Explorer, so you'll need to use MSN and Yahoo!'s direct search function. I've used just a couple examples below, but you can use dozens of keywords and phrases to find pages that use this text and link to the competition.
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "cheap airfare" -site:sidestep.com
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "ticket prices" -site:sidestep.com
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com "cheap airfare" -site:sidestep.com
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com "ticket prices" -site:sidestep.com
Extension-Specific Link Searches:
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com site:gov
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com site:edu
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com site:gov
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com site:edu
Direct-Path-to-Inclusion Link Searches:
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "add url"
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "submit site"
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "directory"
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "suggest a link"
- MSN - linkdomain:sidestep.com "suggest site"
- All the above apply directly to Yahoo! as well
Multiple Competitors at a Time:
This is one of my favorite link searches, as it shows you hubs that have linked to several competing sites. These pages are often easier to get mentions from than standard link searches, because they're already pointing to several folks in the same space.
- MSN - (linkdomain:sidestep.com linkdomain:orbitz.com linkdomain:travelocity.com) (-linkdomain:farecast.com)
- Yahoo! - linkdomain:sidestep.com linkdomain:orbitz.com linkdomain:travelocity.com -linkdomain:farecast.com
Non-Link Link Searches (using normal queries rather than link commands):
This works particularly well at Google since they don't allow advanced link searches.
- Google - cheapflights.com -farecast -site:cheapflights.com
- Google - orbitz travelocity cheaptickets -farecast
- Google - orbitz -farecast -site:orbitz.com
- Google - sidestep "compare airfare" -farecast -site:sidestep.com
Blog & News Link Searches:
- Technorati - orbitz.com (sort by authority)
- Technorati - sidestep airfare
- Topix - orbitz.com
- Topix - sidestep airfare
- GG News - orbitz sidestep -farecast
- GG News - compare airfare - farecast - not really a competitive link search, but a good one to use in general
With the list above, a dedicated link builder could imagine thousand of permutations. It makes me glad I'm in the content and linkbaiting business more these days :)
If you've got competitive searches to add to the list, please do!
Have you tried Trabber.com? is a search engine that aggregate content from online travel agencies, tradicional and low cost websites. Here is the address: www.trabber.com I think you will find it interesting.
Thanks for the info, will ad them to my current process!
Last week some people left comments for tools they made using these parameters.
I would love to see some of those again.
Also, a question.
- I loved your "linkdomain:sidestep.com "cheap airfare" -site:sidestep.com." I think it is incredibly useful, but I am wondering, what if your top competitor for a particular term is a deep linked subpage? linkdomain: won't work(at least in yahoo) for a subpage.
Is there some kind of "linkpage:" command that I can use instead?
Usually if you aren’t Chinese, you can’t get the lowest prices for flights in China, but my foreign friends recently found a site https://www.bamboobookings.com that gets them the same lowest prices as native Chinese citizens. Highly recommend!
one more website www.ayushitravel.com
Nice Post Rand, I discovered after years, but the info is still usefull. We are running a Travel Airfare Metasearch Engine vuelomania.com and defintely we will base our analisis en your methodology.
Thanks again
Hi Rand,
Great post regarding competitor linkbuilding. Though, I came across it late, really helped me alot. These are definitely better ways to increase the rankings of the site sooner.
Once again thanks for providing some great guidelines.
Rand this is another terrific article. It seems that you could burn through a lot of client hours just doing link building. At SEOMOZ do you limit your client link building efforts to a certain percentage of the overall campaign hours (say 15-20%)?
Great info Rand...the only thing I'll "disagree" with is the searching for the sites that have pages that show up for "Add URL", "Submit site", "Directory", "Suggest site", etc.... Those searches tend to bring up SEO'd sites...and the pages they're looking to put on you on are "link" pages. The problems with this (I believe) is that: engines might not count those pages because: they're "clear" "link pages", not "real" votes, and I not sure I trust that sites backlinks (prob all link trade pages)....and prob that site's linking out to all those site (artifical backlinks, too many traded, too high a precentage of trading with sites you're also linking out to, putting your site in the neighborhood of "SEO'd site" (not natural sites), etc, etc. I'd actually try to stear away from the sites that trying to put you on link pages, or that are "SEO link trade neighborhoods".
Good points Jim. I'd counter only that in many niches, those sites are perfectly legitimate and not overly "SEO'd" - some sectors, like insurance or finance or many head-of-tail terms are certainly getting a lot of low quality stuff, but we've had success with those links enough to make it at least worth a search through the results.
Great post Rand! I like your methodology, as always.
Thanks for taking the time to go through this example.
:) CB
as always, you provide just what i'm looking for right when i need it! (although i did have to think a bit about what you meant by a "non-link link search") thanks, rand!
Tmie for another clarification question:
What exactly does this "Non-Link Link Searches" do for us and how does it work? Why would I want to search for two competitors and one keyword at the same time? What does adding the site name with a minus sign in front of it do?
Also, in terms of the issue of search for add a link and the like, it seems to me that the best practice is to check out what types of sites are showing up and then determine whether or not it is worth pursuing this avenue. For some sites it may be worthwhile, for others not. The only way to find out is to get "out there" and see what's doing.
The "non-link" searches can show you valuable places where your competitors have a listing that Google considers important. Since it's not a true "link" search, it might just have their name, but oftentimes there's a link as well. It's just more creative competitive intelligence. :)
Live.com's linkfromdomain: https://blogs.msdn.com/livesearch/archive/2006...
As softplus mentions, it is useful for competitive link analysis as well as analyzing a potential client's website. It simply lists the outbound links for a domain (doesn't support subdomain).
Also on that blog, check out the previous entry on macro searching, it's a fun tool for customizing search results to a specified list of domains. You can then embed the macro into your website.
What about using the new linkfromdomain: MSN query? You can get some really interesting results out of that -- it'll tell you a lot about connections between sites and it might keep you from trying to get links from a group that is already "sold" on the competitor.
I'd love to see an example or blog post on the subject if you've got one to link to :)
Man, I love your step by step case studies...They are so helpful. I just wish that more people would open up the industry as well as you do. Thanks
nice guidelines provided for competitive link searching .
I find it very difficult to discover my target specially but after reading this article i started doing it with ease .
"https://www.stlucia.cc"