The John Lewis Christmas 2013 campaign has smashed it virally. Since it launched two weeks ago it's had:
- 8 million views on YouTube
- 150k Twitter mentions
- 70k Facebook interactions
As content marketers, those kind of engagement statistics seem incredible. Admittedly, brand marketers have much bigger budgets, but as content marketers, what can we learn from brand marketers about creating, launching and promoting content?
If you're in the UK, then you will undoubtedly have seen it, but for everyone else, here's the video:
If you're a bit skeptical and think that content marketing and big brand marketing are totally different, then read this quote from industry marketing bible The Drum:
"Shares are the currency of social success and for leading brand marketers discovering how to create and distribute highly shareable content repeatedly and at scale is now at the top of their wish list."
Sounds familiar, right? Basically big brand marketing and content marketing are converging.
Hopefully you've bought into the idea that we're becoming the same industry…so what can we learn?
Lesson 1: Don't launch on your own site (launch where your target market is)
John Lewis is a big brand, but they didn't launch their campaign on their site. They launched their campaign via Twitter and YouTube.
Why? Because that's where their target market is, that is where they are going to get traction with their audience, and that is where they have the highest chance of virality.
Lesson: Could you launch your content where your target market is? A great example of this happening in the SEO community is Stephen Pavlovich's Definitive Guide To Conversion Rate Optimisation. It's a fantastic piece of content that was launched on Moz and helped to build Stephen's name in the industry.
Pro Tip 1: If you're worried about losing link equity, use the cross domain rel=canonical tag to transfer value back to your site.
Pro Tip 2: If you can't get your content onto a platform where your target audience is, can you use paid promotion to get your content on there?
Lesson 2: Don't make links your main objective
We all want more links. But at Distilled we're now optimising campaigns for other metrics as well.
Question: Would you rather build your brand with new audiences or would you prefer a link from a DA30 site on a page that nobody ever visits and that provides zero referral traffic?
Lesson: Set your content objectives not purely on links or views, but on other levels of engagement. Still factor in links but consider other metrics like sharing, data capture, brand uplift, or online purchases/enquiries.
Lesson 3: Target your content broadly
When you're creating content at the level of John Lewis, then arguably your audience is the entire population.
As content marketers, we've got narrower audiences, but there's a fine line between targeting your content too broadly:
and targeting your content too narrowly:
Lesson: Make sure that the audience that you are targeting for your content piece is large enough to achieve your objectives. Otherwise you have failed from the start.
Pro Tip 1: If you're worried about the reach of your target audience, try and combine several audiences into one content piece. Wiep Knol in his Searchlove 2010 presentation (no longer available, unfortunately) gave a great example of combining several target audiences with his piece the "70 Most Beautiful Churches In Europe," which brought the travel blogging and religious communities together.
Pro Tip 2: Another way you can target content more broadly is geographically. Bingo site TwoLittleFleas has used a US/UK switch on their quiz to broaden their potential audience from 63m (UK population) to 377m (US and UK population).
Pro Tip 3: Another way of targeting your content is including many niche audience groups within a piece of content. This works as the piece of content speaks to pre-existing communities, and their automatic thought when seeing the piece is "that's for me!."
The "From Gospel to Grunge: 100 Years of Rock" piece is not just for people interested in music, it also references various music communities and that will encourage people to engage with the piece.
Lesson 4: Build influencers into your content
John Lewis has embedded an influencer with a massive online community directly into their content. Lily Allen is singing on the ad, which is a pretty clever play from John Lewis considering that she's got 4.3m followers on Twitter.
Lesson: Build influencers into your content launch plan. Ask them to contribute or comment, give them a free trial, or offer them beta access.
Pro Tip: When doing outreach, find people who you can help out. This changes the mindset from "what can this person do for me" to "how can I help this person" (great tip from Marco Montemagno at SearchLove 2013).
Lesson 5: Focus your marketing on innovators/opinion leaders
Hat tip to Seth Godin (and his Purple Cow) for this one. Why did John Lewis launch their campaign online, even though TV is the primary channel? Because online is where innovators and opinion leaders hang out. These are the people that are on the lookout for something new or different. Innovators and opinion leaders have the ability to change the behaviour of the early and late majority.
Lessons: Opinion leaders matter. Use this process from Richard Baxter to find the influencer intersect for your market, and then build relationships with these people as a long term strategy for success in your space.
Lesson 6: Get your creative right (people need to love your marketing)
Didn't you know? Google and other social networks (particularly Facebook), are filtering content through to you based on what they think you'll like. Just because you're publishing content doesn't mean your audience is getting it. (not convinced, read this book).
If other people are reading and sharing though, then your content is likely to get through the filters. So people really do need to love your marketing for it to work.
So, how can you get your creative up to scratch?
If you're just starting out with content marketing, then there are a few things you need to do first:
- Manage expectations and educate internally that content marketing plays like this can fail.
- Do something small first that requires limited budget. Build confidence. Get buy in from the C-suite. THEN go big!
Pro Tip 1: Mitigate risk. Offset some of the risks of content marketing by emulating the fundamentals of a piece that has ALREADY been successful in a different geographical location or industry.
Pro Tip 2: Need creative inspiration? Check out this great post from Kelsey Libert on creative ideation, or this classic from Larry Kim "How I got a link from the Wall Street Journal".
Lesson 7: Spend more on outreach than you are spending on content creation
The John Lewis campaign cost £7m. £6m is going to promotion (advertising). £1m went to creative.
What ratios are you working on in terms of spend on content creation to outreach? The loud and clear message here is that in brand marketing outreach isn't an afterthought. It's fundamental to the campaign.
Lesson: Double your outreach budget. Do outreach yourself? Spend twice the amount of time on it for your next project.
Lesson 8: Keep your content non-promotional (but plan for sales post-launch)
If people feel that they are being sold to, they are less likely to share. So keep your content as non-promotional as possible.
Lesson: For your next piece of content, strip out your sales focused header and footer, and remove the sales spiel and the 'buy' call to action. This is an example piece of content marketing for Simply Business. As you can see, the content, sharing and utility of the piece is the main focus, not any specific marketing or commercial messages.
Pro Tip: Add remarketing tags to your content so you can promote to your audience at a later date (even if it's just to promote your next content piece).
Lesson 9: Are you creating a reaction with your audience?
What reaction are you stirring up in your audience? Is it curiosity, surprise, sorrow or pride?
Interestingly, John Lewis adverts are deliberately sad and they evoke an emotional reaction with their choice of music and the story.
Lesson: At the concept stage, if your concept doesn't evoke a visible reaction with a small group of users, consider it a no-go. No reaction = No social shares.
Conclusion
As content marketers, we know a lot of the strategies and tactics that brand marketers are using. But there's a big difference between knowing what to do, and actually doing it.
In my opinion, there's still a lot we can learn from brand marketers, specifically in terms of strategy, scale, reporting and measurement, and ultimately in the results they get. I'm excited about the way that our two industries are converging.
If you need more inspiration here are a list of resources that I follow to keep up to date with the creative digital sector, and of how I keep up to date with what people love online:
Ads/PR/content making waves:
- Top 20 Most Shared Ads of 2013
- AdAge Viral Video Charts (updated each week)
- Adage Creativity Pick (updated daily)
- Adweek Adfreak
- PR Examples (sign up for the email newsletter)
-
Buzzsumo (my new favourite tool for find out what's big on any website. It's fast, low on bugs and gives you accurate share counts for facebook, G+ and Twitter)
Hope you enjoyed the piece, if you've got any examples of great content marketing or brand marketing that have blown you away, drop them in the comments. Would love to see them.
How about the $11M budget. Isn't that a lesson in itself >>good marketing has a price tag.
Hi Magdalena, that's a great point, and I would agree that as a marketer you have to be prepared to take risk and spend money.
However, I don't think with content marketing that you always have to have a big budget though.
A great example is this 'Why Generation Y Yuppies are Unhappy'. It's had over 500k likes and shares and over 500 linking root domains, and been featured all over the web (including HuffPo) and I can't think the budget was that high...
Let's also not forget that big brands have more bureaucracy and less efficiency than little guys. It doesn't take $11million to make a video that hits on emotional triggers for people. It takes one person with an idea, and a team of people to bring it to life (and not necessary to hire a big brand to do this for you). Sure, you may not be able to capitalize on Lilly Allen singing in your song, but you don't have to.
Great post. I would definitely agree that you need to spend more time today with outreach and promoting your content if you want it to succeed than you ever had to in the past. I always like reading new insights on how an individual or business was able to promote their content in a new way and reach a new segment of their target market that they were not reaching before.
Hi Jeff,
Thanks for the comment. It seems obvious when you look at the ratio of creative:promotion on the John Lewis figures. Why bother creating something if you don't allocate enough time to outreach?
I have to say though, I wouldn't have used these ratios before, but I'm seriously considering it now...
I do enjoy the John Lewis christmas adverts, although thought last years was better than this one.
Do you know if, in that £1m for creative costs of the advert, did that include paying for Lily Allen? Not sure if they will have included that figure as I would have presumed she would have been payed more? (I'm probably wrong).
I wonder how much John Lewis considered all the elements that you mentioned, such as Lily Allen's Twitter followers when they hired her for the advert and I wonder also how much this advert will help John Lewis over the christmas period (will be very interested to see).
Thanks for the interesting & nicely up to date post, James!
Hi Sam,
Thanks for your comment!
Great point about whether the cost of creative was £1m including Lily Allen or not. I got the stat from The Telegraph article which states that "John Lewis alone is spending £7 million on its Christmas campaign (the advert itself cost £1 million)."
That makes it seem like the creative (including Allen) cost £1m, but I'm not 100% on this.
I wonder if Lily Allen took a reduced fee for the advert on the basis that she was about to launch her new album and needed to build her brand awareness again?
In answer to your question about takings, they've just broken several revenue records since the advert launched, so it seems to be doing pretty well for them so far!
If that fee includes Lilly Allen, then I definitely think John Lewis got a great deal! I suppose that even if John Lewis aren't paying Lily Allen directly, its still a great deal for her with the exposure, so regardless of the fee I suppose its win win for both of them.
Those figures are quite incredible, amazing how much an advert that shows no product information/specific promotions can have quite such an impact on sales in such a short time period!
What an awesome example! I saw this video a couple weeks ago, too, and it hits all variables of a successful marketing ad. I like what you said about it having to strike some emotional reaction or else it will not get any shares. That can never be any more true. When I saw this video, the first thing I did was share it on a couple of my social media profiles.
Also, thanks for the pointers! I like your advice on launching a campaign where your audience is. Only a handful of people are truly your brand ambassadors. That's why it's smart to engage your less actively engaged audience exactly where they are - YouTube, Facebook - wherever they may be.
Hi James,
Thanks for the comment. I think testing for an emotional reaction is a great way of assessing the quality of an idea before you launch it.
On your second point, I think you're exactly right, the idea of these types of viral content pieces are to attract and grab the attention of people who are not actively engaged and are not currently your customers, and to put it bluntly, get them into the top of the funnel!
Very good posting James,
Like all folks here I'm a digital marketeer, so I find it a little ironic that I became aware of the John Lewis advert via the television, only to then be aware of the social options I could take within the ad which from memory was #bearandhare. They can teach Tesco's a thing or two I think.
Those of a certain age will no doubt remember where the inspiration of this advertisement originates, which I am guessing is 'Watership Down'.
Great ad but still liked the snowman/woman one from last year.
David
Hi David,
Thanks for the feedback. I wouldn't like to comment on where they got their inspiration from, but I have to say I liked the snowman advert more too!
Like the point about not launching on your own site - this is hard for some of us to even imagine but it definitely makes sense. The point of marketing is to get return and obviously some of that will come back around in the form of SEO. Nice post.
Thanks James. If the sign of an informative post is the number of new browser windows I have open by the time I have finished reading, then you nailed it. 6 new pages to read for me.
Hi Mike,
Haha, yep I did put quite a few links in the article. There are some great long reads aswell as some great content marketing examples. Enjoy!
Good post. I am John Lewis (NOT_the_store) and look at things from a different perspective - specifically, do advertising and social media campaigns really make that much difference? Even any difference?
The answer of course is that we don't know because we do not know what the outcomes would have been if the adverts/campaigns had NOT been run.
My post is deliberately provocative - see
https://johnlewissite.wordpress.com/2013/11/07/on-creatives-being-digital-a-thought-experiment/
My prediction is that John Lewis (the store) will have a good Christmas/New Year trading period and M&S will not have a very good one (except for food) but how much of their relative performance is due to their adverts?
Personally, I'd rather chew glass than listen to Katy Perry whereas I confess to having a crush on Mrs Craig. I shop at John Lewis (online and white goods only) and hate M&S (full of old women, treat customers badly, horrible to suppliers, food/wine overpriced).
In reality, apart from food and antiques, I have bought almost exclusively on-line for the past 10 years. Tesco, Sainsburys, Asda, Morrisons are not going to get my Christmas food/wine spend.
Seasons greetings from a Scrooge.
you think this is a good campaign? great!
Great piece James. I think Lesson 8: Keep your content non-promotional is hard to overstate. If reach is a primary objective, just remember, that virtually noone will share what they perceive as ads. One of my favorite examples is https://youtu.be/AMpZ0TGjbWE (Official Ram Trucks Super Bowl Commercial "Farmer") which follows your Lesson 1, Don't launch on your own site.
Hi Rick,
Thanks for the comment. Yes I agree, it's a really subtle one, but people won't link to overly promotional content for definite.
I think another related point I've found when I'm working with clients is 'how linkable is your site'. You can have the greatest piece of content in the world, but if your site doesn't feel right (design, UX, copy) people simply won't link to it...
Good post and practical advice James
I think advertising and social media campaigns really make a difference.
Thanks for the interesting reading !
James, can you elaborate on this statement for me:
Pro Tip 1: If you're worried about losing link equity, use the cross domain rel=canonical tag to transfer value back to your site.
How do you recommend we make use of this advice in the context of this article? Most of this post is about using Youtube/FB/T, where this wouldn't apply.
You make it sound so simple, but this is a big consideration!
Thanks :)
Lesson 9 is so important. However, people are easily to ignore it. To better connect with your customers, you need to take the reaction from the visitor and know what they are thinking about.
That's a great review, I like the way you break down the campaign and take the lesson from it, I think we can all learn from this post and do the same to learn from other successful marketing campaigns.
this campaign is a waste of money. Emotional videos entertain people and go viral, it does not mean they build your brand and affect purchase behavior. Of course now one is ready to hear this now.
Marketing should always be a venue on how to earn money and not the other way around. If you are doing it just for the sake of showcasing how glorious your products are, then, it will not work. The best thing that you could do is to work with efficient ways, not just expensive ones.
Hey James,
It's all about how you strategize for your marketing campaign. The primary pre-requisite is target market analysis followed by segmentation and then position your campaign according to that. Focusing on to something innovative mode of promotion is what is required in order to stand out from all. Awesome content also needs a proper segment or platform for better reach and engagement. Sometimes a great content just needs to be positioned properly to grab the expaected juice out of it.
Great lesson learned... thanks for sharing and saving me the 11 million!
Hi Dubs, if only that were true!
Another example of this in the UK happened this weekend with comparethemarket.com, Gary Barlow and Coronation Street.
CTM's adverts have always been driven around engagement with its audience - so creating an ad around a popular social topic (a TV soap in this case, Xmas in the other) and a pop star with an album recently released seems to be a growing trend!
Here's the videos for this campaign:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rq_8pCeoUcI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d754uHOL1HM
Joe - Advantec Internet
Thanks for the links Joe, interesting viewing
I love the practical advise in this blog post. I would love to learn more about how large advertisers send their budgets.
Thanks
Great post James. Apart from having decent budget for marketing, next important thing according to me is its launching platform. I agree with your point regarding launching platforms. There is no point in creating an awesome content if you can't reach out to the right audience. This is the reason many campaigns fail despite of having some brilliant stuff with them.
Hi Praveen,
Thanks for the comment. Totally agree with you. It's always a difficult decision to make when you're worried about losing link equity to your site, so I wouldn't recommend doing it every time, but that the strategy can be really effective in certain circumstances.
First of all we would like to thanks to you you are provide very effective information that no need to launch on your own site launch where your target market is, don't make links, target your content, spent more on out reach these will help us very effectively. Focus on the marketing.
Wow, I didn't realise the difference spent on the creative versus the promotion of this John Lewis advert. I think this is probably where a lot of businesses go wrong (spending a lot of time on the creative rather than promoting it).
"Content is king only when a lot is is spent on promotion too!"
Thanks for the interesting read.
Josh
Cheers Josh. I was really shocked by the difference too. It makes a lot of sense really. Why spend a lot of money on creative if you're not spending a lot on outreach aswell?
I think that we need to get out of the 'build it and they will come' mindset when it comes to content marketing. It just doesn't work.
This links (slightly tangentially) to an awesome post on Rand's blog about '7 unlikely recommendations for startups' and his first point, 'marketing first, product second'. You need to focus on the marketing side of things as much/more as the product/creative.
we've tested this as well. The sweet spot is somewhere in the 70/30 range. 70% outreach and only 30% content broadcasting.
That's a great video; during christmas a lot of big companies run christmas special adverts or promotions. This is the best one of all of them. Great work mate. :)
Needs more infographics, there isn't enough visual clutter on the page to keep me from entirely tuning out.
9 and 11 in your headline, eh?
Nice code. Albert Pike would be proud of you, bro:>
2b1ask1?